BriefLaw.us
Criminal cases

Acquittal

A finding that the prosecution did not prove a criminal charge

In briefAn acquittal is a decision that the prosecution has not proved a criminal charge. It ends the case on that charge in the defendant's favor, and in the United States it is final.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

What it means

An acquittal is a finding of "not guilty." It is not a finding that the defendant is innocent. It means the evidence did not prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

A defendant can be acquitted of some charges and convicted of others in the same trial.

Who can acquit

  • A jury, by returning a verdict of not guilty.
  • A judge, in a trial held without a jury.
  • A judge in a jury trial, by ruling that the evidence is too weak for any reasonable jury to convict. In federal court this is a judgment of acquittal under Rule 29.

Why it is final

The Double Jeopardy Clause of the Fifth Amendment bars a second trial for the same offense after an acquittal. The government cannot appeal a not-guilty verdict or ask for a new trial, whatever new evidence turns up later.

The Supreme Court has applied this rule strictly.

CaseRule
Fong Foo v. United States (1962)An acquittal ordered by a judge is final even if it rested on a serious error
Evans v. Michigan (2013)The same is true where the judge acquitted because of a mistake about what the law required
McElrath v. Georgia (2024)A jury's not-guilty verdict is final even if it contradicts another verdict the same jury returned

There is one situation in which a judge's acquittal can be undone. If a jury convicts and the judge then sets the verdict aside, the government can appeal, because reversing the judge would simply restore the jury's verdict without a second trial.

An acquittal and similar outcomes

OutcomeCan the defendant be tried again?
AcquittalNo
Hung jury (no verdict)Yes
Dismissal before trialUsually yes, unless the dismissal is "with prejudice"
Conviction reversed on appeal for a trial errorYes
Conviction reversed because the evidence was insufficientNo; this counts as an acquittal

What an acquittal does not prevent

  • A prosecution by a different government. A state and the federal government may each prosecute the same conduct under their own laws (Gamble v. United States, 2019).
  • A civil lawsuit. The victim can still sue for damages, where the standard of proof is lower.
  • A record of the arrest. The arrest and charge may stay on a person's record unless state law allows them to be sealed or erased.

Acquitted conduct at sentencing

A defendant convicted of one charge and acquitted of another could, for decades, have the acquitted conduct counted in setting the sentence; the Supreme Court allowed this in United States v. Watts (1997). Since November 2024 the federal sentencing guidelines no longer count conduct for which a defendant was acquitted in federal court when calculating the guideline range. The change is limited. Conduct that also proves the crime of conviction still counts, and judges keep some power to consider acquitted conduct when choosing the final sentence.

Related entries