Alford plea
A guilty plea from a defendant who still says he is innocent
In briefAn Alford plea is a guilty plea in which the defendant does not admit the crime. The defendant says he is innocent but accepts that the prosecution's evidence would probably convict him, and takes the conviction to avoid a worse outcome at trial.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
Where it comes from
Henry Alford was charged in North Carolina with first-degree murder, which then carried the death penalty. The evidence against him was strong. He pleaded guilty to second-degree murder to avoid a possible death sentence, while telling the court he had not killed anyone. He was sentenced to 30 years.
Alford later argued the plea was forced on him. In North Carolina v. Alford (1970), the Supreme Court disagreed. It held that a court may accept a guilty plea from a defendant who claims innocence, as long as two things are true:
- the plea is a voluntary and informed choice among the options the defendant has, and
- the record shows strong evidence of guilt.
What it means afterward
An Alford plea is a conviction. The sentence, the criminal record and the other consequences are the same as for an ordinary guilty plea. The defendant gives up the right to a trial.
What the defendant keeps is the refusal to admit the act. That can matter to the person. It gives less protection in a later civil lawsuit than a no contest plea does, because an Alford plea is still a form of guilty plea.
How it differs from no contest
| Plea | What the defendant says | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Guilty | I did it | Conviction |
| No contest (nolo contendere) | I will not fight the charge | Conviction |
| Alford | I did not do it, but the evidence would convict me | Conviction |
A no contest plea neither admits nor denies the charge. An Alford plea goes further and asserts innocence.
Limits
- No right to one. The Supreme Court said in Alford that states may refuse to allow such pleas, and a judge may decline to accept one in a given case.
- Not available everywhere. A few states do not permit Alford pleas.
- Rare in federal court. Federal prosecutors need approval from senior Justice Department officials before agreeing to one.
- A factual basis is still needed. The judge must be satisfied that the evidence supports the charge.