BriefLaw.us
Family

Annulment

A court ruling that a marriage was never legally valid

In briefAn annulment is a court order declaring that a marriage was never legally valid. A divorce ends a valid marriage; an annulment says that, because of a defect present at the wedding, there was no valid marriage to end. It is granted only on specific grounds set by state law, and a short marriage is not one of them.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

Annulment and divorce

AnnulmentDivorce
What the court decidesThe marriage was invalid from the beginningA valid marriage is over
What must be shownA specific legal defect that existed when the couple marriedWhatever the state requires to end a marriage
Legal effectThe marriage is treated as if it never happenedThe marriage existed and has ended

Agreement between the spouses is not enough. In California, for example, a judge must hear why the marriage was never valid even when both of them want the annulment.

Void and voidable marriages

The law separates two kinds of defective marriage.

  • A void marriage was never valid at all. The standard examples are bigamy, where one person was already married, and incest, a marriage between close relatives.
  • A voidable marriage counts as valid until a court declares otherwise. If nobody challenges it, it stands.

Common grounds

Each state has its own list. These grounds appear in many of them:

  • one person was already married to someone else
  • the two are too closely related
  • one person was under the legal age to marry
  • fraud: one person was deceived into marrying
  • force or coercion
  • one person lacked the mental capacity to understand what marriage means

Some states add others. California, for example, allows an annulment when one spouse is physically unable to consummate the marriage and the condition is permanent.

Courts read these grounds narrowly. In California the fraud must be serious, go to the heart of the marriage, and be a reason the person would not otherwise have married.

Time limits

A voidable marriage usually has to be challenged within a set time, and the limits vary by state and by ground. California shows how they can work:

Ground in CaliforniaDeadline to file
Under 18 at the wedding without court approval4 years after turning 18
Fraud4 years after discovering the fraud
Force4 years after the wedding
Physical inability to consummate4 years after the wedding

In California a person who misses the deadline, or does not qualify, can still end the marriage by divorce or legal separation.

Property, support and children

Because an annulled marriage is treated as if it never existed, the rules of divorce do not apply automatically. In California a judge can divide property and debts or order spousal support only for a "putative spouse," meaning one who believed in good faith that the marriage was legal. If both knew it was not, neither can ask for those orders.

An annulment does not leave children without protection. In California, once parentage is established, a judge can make custody, visitation and child support orders as in any other case.

A prenuptial agreement may also be affected. Florida's statute, for example, enforces one after a marriage is declared void only as far as needed to avoid an unfair result.

Related entries