BriefLaw.us
Crimes

Arson

Deliberately and unlawfully setting fire to property

In briefArson is the crime of deliberately and unlawfully setting fire to property. It is treated as one of the most serious property crimes because fire so easily endangers lives.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

From the common law to today

At common law, arson was the malicious burning of the dwelling house of another. Each part of that definition was a limit: the building had to be a home, and it had to be someone else's. The crime protected the safety of people where they lived.

Modern statutes have removed those limits.

ElementCommon lawMost modern statutes
What is burnedA dwellingAny building, and often vehicles, boats, forests and other property
Whose propertyAnother person'sAnyone's, including the defendant's own, especially when the aim is to collect insurance
HowBurningBurning or use of explosives

What must be proved

  1. A burning. Some damage by fire is required, though it can be slight. In many states charring is enough, while smoke stains or scorching are not.
  2. Intent. The fire must be set willfully and maliciously. An accidental fire is not arson, even a careless one. Some states have a separate, lesser crime for recklessly causing a fire.
  3. Property covered by the statute.

Degrees

States grade arson by the danger to people.

  • The most serious degree usually involves an occupied building or a home, or a fire that injures someone.
  • Lower degrees cover empty buildings, vehicles and other property.
  • Burning to defraud an insurer is often its own offense.

A death caused by arson is commonly treated as murder under the felony murder rule, even if no one was meant to be hurt.

Federal law

Most arson is prosecuted by the states. Federal law covers three main situations.

LawWhat it coversPrison term
18 U.S.C. § 844(i)Burning or bombing property used in interstate or foreign commerce, or in an activity that affects it5 to 20 years; 7 to 40 years if someone is injured; any term of years, life or death if someone is killed
18 U.S.C. § 844(f)Property owned, possessed or leased by the United States or by an organization receiving federal funds5 to 20 years; 7 to 40 years if someone is injured or put at substantial risk; at least 20 years, life or death if someone is killed
18 U.S.C. § 81Arson on federal land and territoryUp to 25 years; any term of years or life if the building is a dwelling or a life is put in danger

The reach of the federal law

The requirement of a link to interstate commerce sets a real limit.

  • Russell v. United States (1985): renting out an apartment building is a commercial activity, so burning it is a federal crime.
  • Jones v. United States (2000): a private home that its owner lives in is not, even if it has a mortgage, insurance and gas service from out of state. Burning it is a matter for state law.

Investigation

Arson is hard to prove because the fire destroys evidence. Cases usually rest on signs that a fire was set, such as traces of an accelerant or more than one point of origin, together with evidence of motive.

Related entries