BriefLaw.us
Crimes

Bigamy

Marrying one person while still legally married to another

In briefBigamy is the act of marrying a person while still legally married to someone else. It is against the law in every state, and the second marriage has no legal effect.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

Bigamy and polygamy

Bigamy is the legal offense: entering a second marriage while the first is still in force. Polygamy is the practice of having more than one spouse at a time. A polygamous marriage is bigamous in law, and the two words are often used for the same thing.

The elements

  1. The defendant was legally married.
  2. The marriage had not ended by death, divorce or annulment.
  3. The defendant married another person. Some states also cover living with another person as a spouse.

In many states the person who knowingly marries someone already married also commits a crime.

Defenses

States recognize some or all of these.

  • Belief that the spouse was dead. Typically the spouse must have been absent and unheard from for a set number of years, often five or more.
  • Belief that the first marriage had legally ended, for example reliance on a divorce decree that turned out to be invalid.
  • The first marriage was itself void.

States differ on whether an honest mistake is enough or the mistake must also be reasonable.

Penalties

Bigamy is a felony in most states and a misdemeanor in some. Prison terms of up to several years are possible, though prosecutions are uncommon and usually involve some further wrong, such as fraud or abuse.

Utah changed its law in 2020. Bigamy between consenting adults is now an infraction, comparable to a traffic ticket. It remains a felony to draw someone into a bigamous marriage by fraud, threat or coercion, or to commit certain other crimes alongside it, such as abuse, kidnapping or sexual offenses.

Civil consequences

  • The second marriage is void. It is treated as never having existed, and no divorce is needed to end it, though a court order confirming this is often wise.
  • The innocent partner may have some rights under state law, for example to property or support, if they married in good faith.
  • Immigration. A person coming to the United States to practice polygamy can be refused an immigrant visa, and practicing polygamy can block naturalization.

The constitutional question

In Reynolds v. United States (1879), a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in Utah Territory argued that the federal law against bigamy violated his freedom of religion, since his church then taught plural marriage as a duty. The Supreme Court upheld his conviction. It drew a line that still matters: the First Amendment protects religious belief absolutely, but government may regulate conduct.

"Laws are made for the government of actions, and while they cannot interfere with mere religious belief and opinions, they may with practices."

The church formally renounced the practice in 1890, though some plural marriages continued into the early 1900s. In 1894 Congress made Utah's admission as a state conditional on a permanent ban on polygamy. Utah joined the Union in 1896 with that ban in its constitution, where it remains.

Challenges since have not changed the rule. Obergefell v. Hodges (2015), which recognized a right of same-sex couples to marry, spoke of marriage between two people and did not address plural marriage.

Related entries