BriefLaw.us
Legal tests

Burden of proof

Who has to prove a case, and how convincingly

In briefThe burden of proof is the duty to prove a disputed fact in court. It answers two questions: which side has to prove it, and how convincing the proof must be.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

Who carries it

The side that brings the case usually carries the burden.

  • Criminal cases: the prosecution must prove every element of the crime. The defendant does not have to prove innocence, or prove anything at all.
  • Civil cases: the plaintiff must prove the claim.

If the evidence leaves the question evenly balanced, the side with the burden loses.

The standards of proof

StandardWhat it meansWhere it is used
Preponderance of the evidenceMore likely true than notMost civil lawsuits
Clear and convincing evidenceHighly probableCivil cases with more at stake, such as committing a person to a hospital or ending parental rights
Beyond a reasonable doubtNo reasonable doubt remainsCriminal convictions

Two lower thresholds apply before trial and are not standards for deciding a case: reasonable suspicion, which lets police briefly stop a person, and probable cause, which is needed for an arrest or a search warrant.

Why criminal cases use the highest standard

In In re Winship (1970), the Supreme Court held that the Constitution's guarantee of due process requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt of every fact needed to make out the crime. The Court's reasoning was that a wrongful conviction costs a person liberty and reputation, so the risk of error should fall on the government.

The middle standard has a constitutional floor too. In Addington v. Texas (1979), the Court held that a state must show clear and convincing evidence before committing a person to a mental hospital against their will.

Two burdens in one

Lawyers split the burden into two parts:

  • The burden of production is the duty to offer enough evidence for the issue to be considered at all.
  • The burden of persuasion is the duty to convince the judge or jury to the required standard.

The two can sit with different sides at different times in a trial.

When the defendant has a burden

A criminal defendant sometimes carries a burden on a defense that he raises himself, such as insanity. The Supreme Court allowed this in Patterson v. New York (1977), as long as the prosecution still has to prove every element of the crime itself.

The rules differ by state and by defense. For self-defense, nearly every state makes the prosecution disprove it once the defendant raises it.

Related entries