Bush v. Gore
The 2000 case that ended the Florida recount and settled a presidential election
The ruleA statewide manual recount that lets each county apply its own standard for judging a ballot violates the Equal Protection Clause.
Still good law?In part. The opinion said its reasoning was "limited to the present circumstances." It has not been overruled, but the Supreme Court has rarely cited it since. Checked November 12, 2026.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
The question
The 2000 presidential election between George W. Bush and Al Gore came down to Florida's 25 electoral votes. After a machine recount, Bush led by a few hundred votes out of nearly six million, and the state certified him the winner by 537. Gore contested the result in the Florida courts.
On December 8 the Florida Supreme Court ordered a manual recount of such ballots, called undervotes, in every county that had not already counted them by hand. These were ballots on which machines had detected no vote for president. The only instruction was to look for a "clear indication of the intent of the voter." The next day the U.S. Supreme Court halted the recount, 5–4, while it heard the case.
The question was whether the recount, as ordered, was constitutional.
What the Court held
The Court ruled on December 12 in an unsigned opinion.
The recount violated equal protection. With no uniform rule, the same kind of ballot, such as a punch card with an indented or hanging "chad," could be counted in one county and rejected in the next, or even treated differently by different teams in the same county. Having given people the right to vote, the Court said, a state "may not, by later arbitrary and disparate treatment, value one person's vote over that of another." Seven justices agreed there was a constitutional problem.
There was no time to fix it. The majority read Florida law as intending to finish any contest by December 12, the federal "safe harbor" date after which Congress might not be bound to accept a state's electors. A recount under proper standards could not be completed that day. Five justices therefore ended the recount. Justices Souter and Breyer, who saw the equal protection problem, would have sent the case back for a recount under a uniform standard.
Gore conceded the following day.
How the justices divided
| Position | Justices |
|---|---|
| Equal protection violation; stop the recount | Rehnquist, O'Connor, Scalia, Kennedy, Thomas |
| Also: the Florida court had rewritten the legislature's election law, contrary to Article II | Rehnquist, Scalia, Thomas |
| Equal protection problem, but allow a new recount | Souter, Breyer |
| No violation; the recount should continue | Stevens, Ginsburg |
A decision limited to its facts
The opinion contains an unusual sentence:
"Our consideration is limited to the present circumstances, for the problem of equal protection in election processes generally presents many complexities."
This is why the case has so little weight as precedent. The Supreme Court's majority opinions have cited it rarely since. Lower courts have sometimes applied its equal protection reasoning to voting machines and counting rules, with mixed results.
What it did not decide
- It did not decide who received more votes in Florida. It decided that the recount could not continue.
- It did not hold that all differences between counties in running elections are unconstitutional. The opinion said local bodies may develop different systems.
- It did not adopt the Article II argument that a state court cannot depart from the legislature's rules for choosing electors. Only three justices endorsed it.
What followed
Congress passed the Help America Vote Act in 2002, which paid states to replace punch-card and lever machines and set minimum standards for running federal elections.
The Article II argument returned twenty years later as the "independent state legislature" theory. In Moore v. Harper (2023), a case about congressional maps under the parallel clause on elections to Congress, the Court rejected the strong form of that theory.
In 2022 Congress rewrote the law on counting electoral votes. The old optional "safe harbor" is now a firm deadline for each state to certify its electors, six days before the electors meet.
How later cases have used it
| Case | How it used this one |
|---|---|
| Moore v. Harper (2023) | Held that state legislatures setting rules for congressional elections remain subject to review by state courts, but that state courts "may not transgress the ordinary bounds of judicial review." The Court discussed the concurrence in Bush v. Gore and declined to adopt its test or any other. |
Related entries
- Citizens United v. FECThe 2010 case that allowed unlimited independent political spending by corporations and unions
- PrecedentAn earlier court decision that later courts follow
- CertiorariThe order by which the Supreme Court agrees to hear a case
- Marbury v. MadisonThe 1803 case that lets courts refuse to apply unconstitutional laws
- Baker v. CarrThe 1962 case that let courts hear challenges to unequal legislative districts
Across the Brief network
- Bush v. Gore (2000)The case that ended the Florida recount in the 2000 presidential election, effectively deciding the presidency for George W. Bush
- Bush v. GoreThe Court halts the Florida recount and settles the 2000 election
People in this entry, on BriefPeople