Civil forfeiture
The government's power to take property linked to a crime without charging the owner
In briefCivil forfeiture is a legal process in which the government takes property it says was used in a crime or came from one, without having to charge or convict the owner. The case is brought against the property itself, which is why such cases have names like United States v. $124,700 in U.S. Currency. It differs from criminal forfeiture, which is part of a criminal sentence and requires a conviction.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
How it works
- Seizure. Police or federal agents seize cash, cars, homes or other property they believe is connected to crime, often drug offenses.
- Notice. The government notifies the owner, who must file a claim within a short deadline to contest the forfeiture.
- The case. If the owner contests it, the government must prove the connection between the property and a crime. Under federal law it must do so by a preponderance of the evidence, the ordinary civil standard, rather than beyond a reasonable doubt.
- The proceeds. Forfeited property is sold, and the money usually goes to the agencies involved.
Many owners never contest a forfeiture, because the property is worth less than the cost of a lawyer, and the government then wins by default.
Where it came from
The practice goes back to English admiralty law, under which ships and cargo could be seized for violating customs laws even when their owners were overseas. Early American laws used it against smuggling and piracy. It expanded greatly in the 1980s as part of the war on drugs, when Congress let law enforcement agencies keep forfeiture proceeds.
The leading cases
| Case | Holding |
|---|---|
| Bennis v. Michigan (1996) | 5–4: the state could forfeit a car a wife co-owned after her husband used it with a prostitute, though she knew nothing of it |
| Austin v. United States (1993) | Forfeitures that are partly punishment are subject to the Eighth Amendment's ban on excessive fines |
| Timbs v. Indiana (2019) | Unanimous: the Excessive Fines Clause applies to the states. Indiana sought a $42,000 Land Rover after a drug sale for which the maximum fine was $10,000 |
| Culley v. Marshall (2024) | 6–3: due process requires a timely forfeiture hearing, but not a separate early hearing on whether the government may keep the property in the meantime |
Federal reform and equitable sharing
The Civil Asset Forfeiture Reform Act of 2000 raised the government's burden of proof, created a uniform defense for innocent owners, allowed seized property to be released in cases of hardship, and allowed courts to appoint lawyers in some cases.
Under the federal equitable sharing program, state and local police can transfer a seizure to federal authorities and receive up to 80 percent of the proceeds. Critics say the program lets police avoid stricter state laws. The Justice Department has limited and then expanded it several times as administrations changed.
The states
States have moved in different directions. New Mexico, Montana and Maine have replaced civil forfeiture with criminal forfeiture, which requires a conviction, and North Carolina has long allowed forfeiture in most cases only after a conviction. Nebraska's 2016 reform was meant to do the same but left a gap that lets most civil forfeitures continue. In 2026 Colorado required a related conviction before most forfeitures and gave owners who cannot afford a lawyer the right to one. Many other states have raised the burden of proof, required a conviction in most cases, or redirected proceeds away from police budgets. Some have changed little.
The debate
Supporters say civil forfeiture lets the government take the profits of crime, including from drug traffickers who cannot be prosecuted because they are abroad or have fled. Critics, from both the left and the right, say it gives police a financial incentive to seize property, falls hardest on people who cannot afford to fight, and reverses the presumption of innocence by making owners prove they did nothing wrong.
Related entries
- Money launderingDisguising money from crime so that it appears to come from a lawful source
- Burden of proofWho has to prove a case, and how convincingly
- RacketeeringRunning or taking part in an organization through a pattern of crimes
- Eminent domainThe government's power to take private property for public use