BriefLaw.us
Crimes

Coercion

Forcing someone to act against their will by threats or pressure

In briefCoercion is the use of threats, force or other pressure to make a person do something they would not otherwise do, or to stop them from doing something they have a right to do. The word appears in several parts of the law with different effects.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

As a crime

Many states make coercion a crime of its own. New York's law is an example: a person commits coercion by compelling someone to do something, or not to do something, by making them fear that the person or someone else will cause injury, damage property, commit another crime, accuse them of a crime, expose a secret, abuse an official position, report their immigration status, or do certain other harmful things. Depending on the threat, it can be a misdemeanor or a felony.

Coercion is close to extortion. The difference is the goal. Extortion is aimed at getting property. Coercion is aimed at making the victim act or refrain from acting in some other way.

Federal law uses the idea in particular crimes, such as human trafficking, where forced labor or commercial sex obtained by coercion carries long prison terms, and in election law, which makes it a federal crime to coerce someone to vote or not vote, or to vote for or against a candidate, in a federal election.

In contracts: duress

A contract signed because of an improper threat is voidable by the person who was threatened. They can choose to cancel it. The threat must have left them no reasonable alternative. Threats of violence or of a criminal charge qualify. A threat to do something one has a legal right to do, such as file a lawsuit in good faith or refuse to deal, usually does not.

Hard bargaining and economic pressure are not enough on their own. Courts expect parties to negotiate in their own interest.

As a criminal defense: duress

A person who commits a crime because someone threatened them with death or serious injury may have a defense of duress. Generally the defendant must show:

  1. an unlawful threat of immediate death or serious bodily harm
  2. a well-founded fear that it would be carried out
  3. no reasonable, legal alternative
  4. that they did not recklessly or negligently place themselves in the situation
  5. a direct link between the crime and avoiding the threatened harm

In Dixon v. United States (2006), the Supreme Court held that a defendant charged with federal firearms crimes must prove duress by a preponderance of the evidence, and federal courts generally follow that rule. Under the traditional rule, followed in many states, duress is not a defense to murder; some states allow it.

Coerced confessions

A confession obtained by coercion cannot be used against the person who made it. The Supreme Court has held this since Brown v. Mississippi (1936), in which confessions had been obtained by whipping and mock hanging. The question is whether the statement was voluntary in light of all the circumstances. Physical force, threats and promises of leniency can each make a confession involuntary. In Arizona v. Fulminante (1991), a confession to a government informant who offered protection from other inmates' threatened violence was held coerced. The Court also held that wrongly admitting a coerced confession does not overturn a conviction if the error was harmless.

Consent obtained by coercion

Consent given under coercion is not real consent. This matters for searches, where police may search without a warrant if a person freely agrees, and for sexual offenses, where coercion can make conduct a crime even without physical force.

Coercion of the states

The word has a constitutional meaning too. Congress may attach conditions to money it gives the states, but not conditions so severe that they leave a state no real choice. In National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius (2012), the Court found that threatening to take away a state's existing Medicaid funding if it refused the Affordable Care Act's Medicaid expansion crossed that line.

Related entries