Common law
Law made by judges' decisions instead of by statute
In briefCommon law is law that comes from court decisions. Judges decide a dispute, explain their reasons, and later courts follow that reasoning in similar cases.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
Three meanings of the term
Lawyers use "common law" in three ways, and the meaning depends on what it is being contrasted with.
| Contrasted with | Common law means |
|---|---|
| Statutes | Rules made by judges, not passed by a legislature |
| Civil law | The legal tradition of England and the countries that took their law from it, including the United States |
| Equity | The rules of the old English law courts, as against the separate courts of equity |
The first meaning is the usual one in the United States.
How it works
Common law grows one case at a time. A court's ruling on a legal question becomes a precedent. Under the rule of stare decisis, courts follow their own earlier decisions and those of the courts above them.
A higher court can overrule a precedent, and a legislature can replace a common law rule by passing a statute. When a statute and the common law conflict, the statute controls.
Where it comes from
The common law took shape in England in the century after the Norman Conquest of 1066, as royal judges traveling the country applied the same rules everywhere, a law "common" to the whole kingdom. The American colonies took it with them. After independence the states kept English common law as the base of their own.
Louisiana is the exception. Its private law descends from French and Spanish codes, in the civil law tradition.
Where it still governs
Much of the law of contracts, torts and property is still common law, set state by state. That is why the rule for a negligence claim can differ between two states.
Criminal law has moved the other way. Crimes today are defined almost entirely by statute, and federal courts have had no power to create crimes on their own since United States v. Hudson and Goodwin (1812).
Federal courts and the common law
There is no general federal common law. In Erie Railroad Co. v. Tompkins (1938), the Supreme Court held that when a federal court hears a case governed by state law, it must apply that state's law, including its court decisions. Federal judges cannot substitute their own view of what the common law should be. A small body of federal common law survives in areas of special federal concern.
Terms that come from it
"Common-law marriage" is a marriage recognized without a license or ceremony, under rules courts developed. A "common-law crime" is one defined by courts before legislatures wrote criminal codes.