Commutation
A reduction of a criminal sentence by a president or governor
In briefA commutation is a decision by a president or governor to reduce a criminal sentence. It shortens or lightens the punishment. It does not undo the conviction.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
Commutation and other forms of clemency
| Form | What it does |
|---|---|
| Pardon | Forgives the crime and removes most of its legal consequences |
| Commutation | Reduces the sentence; the conviction stands |
| Reprieve | Delays a sentence, most often an execution |
| Remission | Cancels a fine or forfeiture |
A person whose sentence is commuted remains a convicted felon. Rights lost because of the conviction, such as the right to possess a firearm, are not restored.
Who can commute a sentence
- Federal sentences: the president alone. The Constitution gives the president the power "to grant Reprieves and Pardons for Offenses against the United States, except in Cases of Impeachment," and commutation has always been treated as part of it.
- State sentences: the governor, a clemency board, or the two together, depending on the state. A president cannot commute a state sentence.
What a commutation can do
A commutation can cut a prison term to a shorter one, release a prisoner at once, or change a death sentence to life in prison. It can also come with conditions.
- Biddle v. Perovich (1927): a prisoner's consent is not needed. The president changed a death sentence to life in prison, and the Supreme Court held the prisoner could not refuse it.
- Schick v. Reed (1974): conditions are allowed. The Court upheld a commutation from death to life in prison on the condition that the prisoner never be paroled.
Congress cannot limit the power by statute. Courts do not second-guess the president's reasons, though a condition attached to a commutation must not itself violate the Constitution.
The federal process
Requests go to the Office of the Pardon Attorney in the Justice Department, which reviews them and makes a recommendation. Under the department's rules a person should not apply while other court or administrative relief is still available, and a commutation applies to a sentence that is being served. The president is not bound by the recommendation and may act without one.
Recent large grants
From the 1950s through the 2000s presidents granted few commutations, often a few dozen or fewer. Recent presidents have used the power on a much larger scale.
- President Obama commuted more than 1,700 sentences, most for drug crimes.
- President Biden commuted the sentences of nearly 1,500 people on home confinement in December 2024. Later that month he changed the sentences of 37 of the 40 people on federal death row to life without parole, and in January 2025 he commuted nearly 2,500 drug sentences.
- President Trump commuted the sentences of 14 people convicted over the January 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol on the first day of his second term, while pardoning the others. In 2026 the courts, at the Justice Department's request, vacated the convictions of 12 of the 14 and dismissed the charges.
How it differs from parole and early release
A commutation comes from the executive as an act of clemency. Parole is granted by a parole board under rules set by law. A court's reduction of a sentence, such as compassionate release, is a judicial decision under a statute. All three can free a prisoner early, but only clemency is left almost entirely to the executive's discretion.
Related entries
- PardonAn act of forgiveness that removes the punishment for a crime
- ParoleSupervised release from prison before a sentence has ended
- Life imprisonmentA sentence to prison for the rest of a person's life
- Suspended sentenceA sentence the court imposes but does not carry out, on conditions
- AcquittalA finding that the prosecution did not prove a criminal charge
- SeditionStirring up or plotting resistance to the government's authority