BriefLaw.us
Torts and injuries

Consent

Voluntary agreement that makes lawful what would otherwise be a wrong

In briefConsent is a person's voluntary agreement to something done to them or their property. In law, valid consent can turn what would otherwise be a wrong, such as touching someone, entering their land or searching their home, into lawful conduct.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

Consent in tort law

Consent is a defense to the intentional torts: battery, assault, false imprisonment and trespass. A boxer cannot sue an opponent for a punch landed within the rules, and a dinner guest is not trespassing.

Consent can be:

  • Express: stated in words or writing
  • Implied by conduct: holding out an arm for a vaccination, or joining a game of football
  • Implied by law: in an emergency, a doctor may treat an unconscious patient on the assumption that a reasonable person would agree

Limits on consent

Consent protects only what was agreed to.

ProblemEffect
Exceeding the scopeConsent to one act is not consent to another. A surgeon who performs a different operation from the one agreed is liable.
Lack of capacityChildren, and adults who cannot understand the decision, cannot give valid consent. A parent or guardian decides for them.
FraudConsent obtained by deceiving the person about the nature of the act is not valid
DuressConsent obtained by threats is not valid
RevocationConsent can generally be withdrawn, and the conduct must stop

Informed consent in medicine

A patient's agreement to treatment counts only if it is informed. A doctor must explain the nature of the procedure, its significant risks, the alternatives, and the risks of doing nothing. In Canterbury v. Spence (1972), a federal appeals court held that the measure is what a reasonable patient would want to know, not merely what other doctors customarily disclose. States are divided between that patient-centered standard and the older professional standard.

Failing to obtain informed consent is usually treated as negligence. Operating with no consent at all is battery.

Consent to searches

Police may search without a warrant if a person voluntarily agrees. In Schneckloth v. Bustamonte (1973), the Supreme Court held that consent is judged from all the circumstances, and that police need not tell a person they have the right to refuse. Earlier, in Bumper v. North Carolina (1968), the Court held that consent given only because officers claimed to have a warrant is not voluntary.

A person who shares a home can usually consent to a search of common areas. But if a co-occupant who is physically present says no, police may not search on the other's consent, at least as to the objector (Georgia v. Randolph, 2006).

Consent in criminal law

  • Generally no defense to serious harm. A person cannot consent to being killed or seriously injured, so consent is not a defense to murder or, in most states, to aggravated assault.
  • Sports and ordinary contact are exceptions for injuries within the normal risks of the activity.
  • Sexual offenses. Lack of consent is the core of most sexual assault crimes. States define consent differently, and some now require affirmative agreement.
  • Age of consent. Each state sets an age, generally from 16 to 18, below which a person cannot legally consent to sexual activity.

Consent in contracts and data

A contract requires each party's genuine assent. Online, courts generally enforce terms of service when the user had reasonable notice of them and clearly agreed, for example by clicking "I agree." Privacy laws in some states require consent before certain personal data is collected or sold.

Related entries