BriefLaw.us
Contracts and business

Contract

An agreement that the law will enforce

In briefA contract is an agreement between two or more parties that the law will enforce. If one side fails to do what it promised, the other can go to court for a remedy.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

What makes a contract

  1. An offer. One party proposes definite terms.
  2. Acceptance. The other agrees to those terms.
  3. Consideration. Each side gives or promises something of value in exchange. A promise of a gift, with nothing given in return, is generally not enforceable.
  4. Capacity. The parties must be able to contract. A contract made by a minor can usually be cancelled by the minor.
  5. A lawful purpose. Courts will not enforce an agreement to do something illegal.

Whether there was agreement is judged from the outside. What matters is what a reasonable person would understand from the parties' words and conduct, not what one of them secretly intended. In Lucy v. Zehmer (Virginia, 1954), a man who signed a sale of his farm on the back of a restaurant check, and later said he had been joking, was held to the deal.

Does it have to be in writing?

Usually not. An oral contract is generally as binding as a written one, though harder to prove. A rule called the statute of frauds requires a signed writing for certain kinds, among them:

  • sales of land
  • agreements that cannot be completed within one year
  • sales of goods for $500 or more
  • promises to pay another person's debt

Under a federal law passed in 2000, a signature or record cannot be refused legal effect just because it is electronic.

Which law applies

Contract law is mostly state law, made by judges over centuries. Sales of goods are governed by Article 2 of the Uniform Commercial Code. Every state except Louisiana has adopted Article 2. Contracts for services, land and employment remain under the common law.

Defenses

A person sued on a contract can argue that it should not be enforced.

DefenseWhat it means
Fraud or misrepresentationAgreement was obtained by a false statement
DuressAgreement was obtained by an improper threat
MistakeBoth sides were wrong about a basic fact
UnconscionabilityThe terms are grossly unfair and one side had no real choice
ImpossibilityAn unforeseen event has made performance impossible

Breach and remedies

A breach is a failure to perform without a legal excuse. The aim of the remedy is to put the injured party where it would have been had the contract been performed. It is not to punish.

RemedyWhen it is used
Expectation damagesThe usual remedy: the value of what was promised, less what was received
Consequential damagesFurther losses, but only those the breaching party could reasonably have foreseen when the contract was made. The rule comes from the English case Hadley v. Baxendale (1854).
Specific performanceA court order to carry out the contract. It is reserved for unique things, chiefly land.
Rescission and restitutionThe contract is undone and each side returns what it received

Punitive damages are generally not available for breach of contract. The injured party must also take reasonable steps to limit its losses.

Parties can agree in advance on the damages for a breach. Courts enforce such a clause if the amount is a reasonable estimate and not a penalty.

Time limits

Each state sets a deadline for suing, commonly three to six years for a written contract and less for an oral one. For sales of goods it is four years, and the contract can shorten it to as little as one.

Related entries