BriefLaw.us
Intellectual property

Copyright infringement

Using a copyrighted work in a way reserved to its owner, without permission

In briefCopyright infringement is copying, adapting, distributing, publicly performing or publicly displaying a copyrighted work without the owner's permission or a legal defense such as fair use. It is mainly a civil matter between the owner and the user, though serious cases can be crimes.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

The rights that can be infringed

The owner of a copyright has the exclusive right to:

  • make copies of the work
  • prepare new works based on it, such as a translation or film version
  • distribute copies to the public
  • perform it in public
  • display it in public

Doing any of these without a license or a legal defense is infringement. Intent is not required. A person who copies innocently is still liable, though the damages may be lower.

What the owner must prove

The Supreme Court stated the test in Feist Publications v. Rural Telephone Service (1991):

  1. Ownership of a valid copyright.
  2. Copying of original parts of the work.

Direct proof of copying is rare. Owners usually show that the defendant had access to the work and that the two works are substantially similar. If the defendant created the same thing independently, there is no infringement, however alike the works are.

Only expression is protected. Ideas, facts, methods and stock elements common to a genre are free for all to use.

Before suing

The owner of a U.S. work must register it with the Copyright Office before filing suit. The office must have acted on the application; applying is not enough (Fourth Estate v. Wall-Street.com, 2019). Registration also affects the remedies: statutory damages and attorney's fees are generally available only if the work was registered before the infringement began.

Remedies

RemedyDetails
InjunctionAn order to stop
Actual damages and profitsThe owner's losses, plus the infringer's profits from the infringement
Statutory damagesInstead of actual damages, $750 to $30,000 per work as the court considers just; up to $150,000 if willful; as low as $200 if the infringer had no reason to know
Costs and attorney's feesAt the court's discretion

Small claims, up to $30,000, can be brought before the Copyright Claims Board, a tribunal in the Copyright Office that has taken cases since 2022. The person accused can opt out within 60 days, which sends the dispute to federal court.

Time limit

A civil suit must be filed within three years after the claim accrues. Many courts start the clock when the owner discovers, or should have discovered, the infringement; the Supreme Court has not decided whether that is right. In Warner Chappell Music v. Nealy (2024), it held that an owner whose claim is timely can recover damages no matter when the infringement occurred.

Defenses

  • Fair use, for purposes such as criticism, news reporting, teaching and research
  • License, including an implied one
  • First sale: the owner of a lawful copy may resell or lend it
  • Independent creation
  • The work is not protected, for example because it is in the public domain

Liability for others' infringement

A person or company can be liable for infringement by someone else.

CaseRule
Sony v. Universal City Studios (1984)Selling a product that has substantial lawful uses, there the home video recorder, is not infringement merely because some buyers misuse it
MGM Studios v. Grokster (2005)Distributing a product with the aim of promoting infringement creates liability
Cox Communications v. Sony Music (2026)An internet provider is not liable for its customers' infringement just because it knew of it and kept serving them. Liability requires that the provider induced the infringement or offered a service tailored to it.

Online services are protected by a "safe harbor" in the Digital Millennium Copyright Act. A service that hosts users' material is not liable for damages if it removes infringing items promptly when the owner sends a proper notice, and has a policy for ending the accounts of repeat infringers, among other conditions. Failing to qualify for the safe harbor does not by itself make a service liable.

When it is a crime

Willful infringement is a federal crime when it is done for commercial gain, involves works worth more than $1,000 in a 180-day period, or consists of posting a work online before its commercial release. The most serious cases carry up to five years in prison, and ten for a repeat offense.

Related entries