BriefLaw.us
Civil lawsuits

Criminal law vs. civil law

The two main kinds of cases, and how they differ

In briefCriminal cases are brought by the government to punish conduct the law defines as a crime; civil cases are disputes, usually between private parties, in which one side seeks money or a court order. A criminal case must be proved beyond a reasonable doubt and can lead to prison or a criminal record; a civil case usually needs only a preponderance of the evidence and leads to money damages or a court order. The same act can lead to both.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

The main differences

CriminalCivil
Who brings itA prosecutor for the government ("The People," "The State," "United States")The person or organization claiming harm, the plaintiff
PurposePunish and deter wrongdoing, and protect the publicCompensate for harm or resolve a dispute
Burden of proofBeyond a reasonable doubtUsually a preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not)
Possible outcomePrison, probation, fines, a criminal recordMoney damages, an order to do or stop doing something
Right to a free lawyerYes, if the person cannot afford one, in felony cases and any case that ends in a jail sentenceGenerally no
Jury verdictMust be unanimous for serious crimes (Ramos v. Louisiana, 2020)Many states allow non-unanimous verdicts; federal civil juries must be unanimous unless the parties agree otherwise
Self-incriminationThe defendant cannot be forced to testifyA party can be required to testify; they can refuse to answer questions that could incriminate them, but the jury may draw an adverse inference from the refusal

One act, two cases

The same conduct can lead to both a criminal prosecution and a civil lawsuit. A drunk driver who injures someone may be prosecuted by the state and also sued by the injured person for medical bills and pain. Because the burdens of proof differ, a person can be acquitted in a criminal case and still be found liable in a civil one, as happened with O. J. Simpson in 1995 and 1997. Double jeopardy, which bars a second prosecution for the same offense, does not prevent a civil lawsuit.

Other meanings of "civil law"

"Civil law" has another meaning. It also names the legal tradition of continental Europe and Latin America, based on comprehensive written codes, in contrast to the common law tradition of England and the United States, in which judges' decisions are a major source of law. Louisiana's private law follows the civil-law tradition. Civil law in that sense covers both criminal and civil matters.

Somewhere in between

Some cases have features of both. Government agencies bring civil enforcement actions seeking fines; civil forfeiture lets the government take property tied to crime without a criminal conviction; and contempt of court can be civil or criminal.

This page describes the law in general terms and is not legal advice.

Related entries