De facto and de jure
What exists in practice, and what exists by law
In briefDe facto is Latin for "in fact" and describes something that exists in practice, whether or not the law recognizes it. De jure means "by law" and describes something that exists because the law says so. The pair is used to separate what is officially so from what is actually so.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
Examples
| De jure | De facto | |
|---|---|---|
| Segregation | Required by law, such as a statute assigning children to schools by race | Arising without a law, for example from where people live |
| A government | The government recognized as lawful | The government actually in control |
| An official | A person lawfully appointed or elected | A person acting in an office under some claim of right, though the appointment was defective |
| A marriage | Entered into under the formal rules | A couple living together as if married (a term used mainly outside the U.S.) |
| A corporation | Properly formed | Formed in good faith but with a defect in the paperwork |
Segregation
The distinction matters most in the law of school desegregation. Brown v. Board of Education (1954) struck down segregation that the law required. In the decades after, courts had to decide whether they could order remedies for segregation that had no statute behind it.
The Supreme Court held that the Constitution reaches only segregation caused by government action. In Keyes v. School District No. 1 (1973), it held that Denver's school board, though no law required segregation, had deliberately segregated schools in one part of the city through its choices of school sites and attendance zones. That was de jure segregation, and it shifted to the board the burden of showing that segregation elsewhere in the city was not intentional. The Court said the difference between the two kinds is "purpose or intent to segregate."
Where segregation resulted from private choices alone, there was no constitutional violation for courts to remedy. In Milliken v. Bradley (1974), the Court held that a court could not order Detroit's suburbs to take part in desegregation unless they or the state had helped cause segregation across district lines.
So in this area "de jure" has come to mean "caused intentionally by government," not only "written into a statute."
The de facto officer
A person who holds an office under color of authority, and whose appointment later turns out to be defective, is a de facto officer. Their official acts are generally treated as valid, so that the public is not harmed by a defect it could not know about.
The Supreme Court has limited the doctrine. In Ryder v. United States (1995), it held that a person who promptly challenges the constitutionality of the appointment of the judges hearing their case is entitled to a ruling on that challenge, and to a new hearing before properly appointed judges if it succeeds.
In international law
Countries recognize foreign governments in one of two ways. De facto recognition acknowledges that a government controls a territory. De jure recognition accepts it as the lawful government. Since the 1970s the United States has generally tried to avoid formal statements about recognizing new governments, and rarely uses the de facto and de jure labels.
In ordinary speech
The words have spread beyond law. A "de facto leader" is one who runs things without the title. A "de facto ban" is a practice that has the effect of a ban without a rule that says so.
Related entries
- Brown v. Board of EducationThe 1954 case that ended legal segregation in public schools
- Plessy v. FergusonThe 1896 case that upheld racial segregation as "separate but equal"
- Sui generisOf its own kind; unlike anything else and needing its own rules
- StatuteA written law passed by a legislature
- Common lawLaw made by judges' decisions instead of by statute
- Prima facieEnough evidence, on first view, to support a claim unless it is answered