BriefLaw.us
Lawyers, judges and officials

District attorney

The elected official who prosecutes crimes in a county or district

In briefA district attorney, or D.A., is the chief prosecutor for a county or judicial district. The office decides whether to bring criminal charges under state law and represents the government in court when it does.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

What the office does

  • reviews arrests and police reports and decides whether to file charges, and which
  • presents cases to a grand jury where one is used
  • negotiates plea agreements
  • tries cases before judges and juries
  • recommends sentences
  • handles some appeals

The elected district attorney sets policy. Most of the daily work is done by assistant or deputy district attorneys.

The victim of a crime is a witness, not a party. The case is brought in the name of the state or the people, and the decision to prosecute or drop a case belongs to the prosecutor, not to the victim.

Names and selection

The title varies by state: state's attorney in Illinois and Maryland, commonwealth's attorney in Virginia and Kentucky, county attorney, prosecuting attorney, solicitor or circuit attorney elsewhere.

In most states the voters of the county or district elect the prosecutor, usually to a four-year term. A few states appoint them. In Alaska, Connecticut, Delaware, New Jersey and Rhode Island, local prosecutors are appointed or work under the state attorney general.

Prosecutorial discretion

A prosecutor has very wide freedom to decide whom to charge and with what. Courts rarely interfere. In Bordenkircher v. Hayes (1978), the Supreme Court held that a prosecutor may threaten more serious charges, if the evidence supports them, to persuade a defendant to plead guilty.

There are limits. A prosecutor may not choose defendants on the basis of race, religion or the exercise of a constitutional right. And a charge needs probable cause.

Special duties

A prosecutor is not an ordinary advocate. In Berger v. United States (1935), the Supreme Court said that the government's interest in a criminal prosecution "is not that it shall win a case, but that justice shall be done."

DutySource
Hand over to the defense evidence favorable to the accused that is important to guilt or punishmentBrady v. Maryland (1963)
Disclose deals made with prosecution witnessesGiglio v. United States (1972)
Not knowingly use false testimony, and correct it when it appearsNapue v. Illinois (1959)
Not exclude jurors because of their raceBatson v. Kentucky (1986)

Accountability

Prosecutors cannot be sued for damages over decisions made as advocates, such as bringing charges and presenting a case, even when they act wrongly (Imbler v. Pachtman, 1976). Later cases give only a weaker, qualified immunity when a prosecutor acts as an investigator.

The checks that remain are elections, discipline by the state bar, review by courts in the case itself, and in some states removal by the governor, the legislature or a court.

District attorneys and other prosecutors

OfficeLevelChosen byProsecutes
District attorneyCounty or districtUsually votersMost state crimes
State attorney generalStateVoters in most statesAppeals, statewide cases, and cases referred by local prosecutors
U.S. attorneyFederal; 93 U.S. attorneys serve the 94 federal districtsThe president, with Senate confirmationFederal crimes
City attorneyCityVariesIn some places, misdemeanors and local ordinance violations

The same act can violate both state and federal law, in which case both a district attorney and a U.S. attorney may prosecute.

Related entries