BriefLaw.us
Constitution and rights

Double jeopardy

The rule against trying a person twice for the same crime

In briefDouble jeopardy is the rule that the government cannot prosecute or punish a person twice for the same offense. It comes from the Fifth Amendment.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

What the Constitution says

"nor shall any person be subject for the same offence to be twice put in jeopardy of life or limb"

The Supreme Court reads this as three protections:

  1. No second prosecution for the same offense after an acquittal.
  2. No second prosecution for the same offense after a conviction.
  3. No more than one punishment for the same offense.

The rule has bound the states as well as the federal government since Benton v. Maryland (1969).

When protection begins

Jeopardy "attaches" at a set moment. In a jury trial it is when the jury is sworn in. In a trial before a judge alone, it is when the first witness is sworn. Charges dropped before that point can be brought again.

What counts as the same offense

Two charges are the same offense unless each one requires proof of a fact the other does not. This is the Blockburger test, from Blockburger v. United States (1932). One act can therefore lead to several charges, as long as each has its own element.

When a second trial is allowed

SituationSecond trial?Why
The jury could not agree (a hung jury)YesThe first trial reached no verdict
The defendant appealed and won a new trialYesThe defendant asked for the conviction to be set aside
The conviction was reversed because the evidence was too weakNoThat counts as an acquittal (Burks v. United States, 1978)
A state and the federal government each prosecuteYesThey are separate governments with separate laws
The victim sues for money after an acquittalYesA civil lawsuit is not a criminal prosecution

Separate governments

The widest limit on the rule is the dual-sovereignty doctrine. A state and the federal government can each prosecute the same conduct, because each is enforcing its own law, and the Court treats those as two different offenses. The Supreme Court reaffirmed this in Gamble v. United States (2019). Two different states can do the same.

An acquittal is final

Once a jury acquits, the prosecution cannot appeal and cannot try again, even if the verdict looks wrong. In McElrath v. Georgia (2024), the Court applied this to a jury whose verdicts contradicted each other: the acquittal still stood.

Related entries