BriefLaw.us
Criminal defenses

Entrapment

A defense when government agents induce a person to commit a crime they were not inclined to commit

In briefEntrapment is a criminal defense that applies when a government agent induces a person to commit a crime the person would not otherwise have committed. Giving a willing person an opportunity to commit a crime, as in an undercover sting, is not entrapment. The defense rests on the idea that the government should catch criminals, not create them.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

What entrapment is not

Giving someone an opportunity to commit a crime is not entrapment. An undercover officer may pose as a drug buyer, offer a bribe to an official suspected of taking them, or set up a fake online profile. Stings like these are lawful as long as the person was already willing to commit the crime.

Entrapment also applies only to the government and those working for it, such as informants. A private person who talks someone into a crime does not create an entrapment defense.

The two tests

TestQuestion askedWho uses it
SubjectiveWas this defendant predisposed to commit the crime before the government got involved?Federal courts and most states
ObjectiveWould the government's conduct have induced a normally law-abiding person to commit the crime?A minority of states, many following the Model Penal Code

The subjective test focuses on the defendant's state of mind. The objective test focuses on the conduct of the police.

The federal rule

Under the subjective test, the defense has two parts.

  1. Government inducement. More than a simple offer: persuasion, pressure, appeals to sympathy or friendship, or repeated requests.
  2. Lack of predisposition. The defendant was not ready and willing to commit the crime before the government's first contact.

The defendant must first present some evidence of inducement. The government must then prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant was predisposed. Predisposition is usually shown by the defendant's prior record, eagerness to take part, or familiarity with the crime.

The leading cases

CaseHolding
Sorrells v. United States (1932)Recognized the defense. A Prohibition agent posing as a furniture dealer used his real shared wartime service with the defendant to ask him repeatedly for liquor until he gave in.
Sherman v. United States (1958)An informant met the defendant at a doctor's office where both were being treated for addiction, and pleaded with him for drugs, citing his own suffering. Entrapment as a matter of law.
United States v. Russell (1973)Supplying a hard-to-get but legal ingredient for making drugs was not entrapment of a predisposed defendant
Mathews v. United States (1988)A defendant may deny committing the crime and still claim entrapment
Jacobson v. United States (1992)Federal agents spent more than two years sending a man mailings before he ordered illegal material. The government had to show he was predisposed before its campaign began, and it had not.

Outrageous government conduct

Some courts recognize a separate defense when the government's conduct is so outrageous that prosecuting the defendant would violate due process, whatever the defendant's predisposition. The Supreme Court suggested such a defense might exist in United States v. Russell (1973) but has never applied it, and it almost never succeeds.

How often it works

Entrapment is raised far more often than it succeeds. Because the defendant usually admits doing the act, the defense is a risky strategy, and juries tend to find predisposition when the defendant took part readily. It is most often raised in drug, bribery, terrorism and online sting cases.

Related entries