Force majeure
A contract clause that excuses performance after events beyond anyone's control
In briefForce majeure is a term for an event beyond the control of the parties to a contract that prevents one of them from doing what it promised. A force majeure clause is the part of a contract that says what happens then.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
Where the rule comes from
In American law, force majeure is not a general legal doctrine. It is a matter of contract. Whether a party is excused depends on the words of the clause the parties wrote, and a contract with no such clause gives no force majeure defense at all.
What a clause usually contains
- A list of events. Typical examples are fire, flood, earthquake, war, terrorism, strikes, epidemics and government orders. Natural events are sometimes called "acts of God."
- A catch-all, such as "or any other cause beyond the party's reasonable control."
- The effect. Performance may be suspended, deadlines extended, or the contract ended if the event lasts long enough.
- Conditions. The party must usually give prompt notice and take reasonable steps to limit the harm.
What a party must show
- The event is covered by the clause.
- The event was beyond the party's control and not its own fault.
- The event actually caused the failure to perform.
- The party could not reasonably have avoided the result.
How courts read the clauses
Courts generally read them narrowly.
- The event must be covered. In New York, a leading commercial jurisdiction, the clause ordinarily excuses a party only if it specifically includes the event that occurred (Kel Kim Corp. v. Central Markets, 1987).
- Catch-alls are limited. General words are often read to cover only events similar to those listed.
- Cost is not enough. A contract that has become more expensive or less profitable is not excused. A market downturn or a rise in prices is a business risk.
- Some courts ask about foreseeability. If the event could have been anticipated and was not listed, the party may be held to have accepted the risk.
Disputes during the COVID-19 pandemic showed how much turns on wording. Clauses that mentioned epidemics, pandemics or government orders often excused performance. Clauses that did not often failed, although some courts treated the pandemic as a "natural disaster" or as covered by a catch-all for events beyond the parties' control.
Without a clause
A party with no clause, or one that does not fit, can turn to three older doctrines. They are harder to meet.
| Doctrine | When it applies |
|---|---|
| Impossibility | Performance cannot be done at all, for example because the subject of the contract was destroyed |
| Impracticability | An event the parties assumed would not happen makes performance extremely and unreasonably difficult. For sellers of goods, this is in Uniform Commercial Code § 2-615. |
| Frustration of purpose | Performance is still possible, but the reason for the contract has disappeared |
What to look for in a contract
Because the wording decides the outcome, the questions to ask of any clause are: which events are listed, whether there is a catch-all, whether payment obligations are excluded, what notice is required, and whether a long delay allows either side to walk away.