BriefLaw.us
Criminal cases

Grand jury

The panel of citizens that decides whether to bring criminal charges

In briefA grand jury is a group of citizens that decides whether prosecutors have enough evidence to charge a person with a crime. It does not decide guilt. If it finds enough evidence, it issues a formal charge called an indictment.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

What the Constitution says

"No person shall be held to answer for a capital, or otherwise infamous crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury"

In practice this means a federal felony charge must come from a grand jury. A defendant can give up that right, except in a death penalty case.

How it works

A federal grand jury has 16 to 23 members. At least 12 must agree to indict. The question is whether there is probable cause to believe the person committed the crime, a far lower bar than the proof needed to convict.

The proceeding looks nothing like a trial:

  • It is secret. Jurors, prosecutors, court reporters and interpreters may not disclose what happens. Witnesses are free to say what they told the jury.
  • There is no judge in the room, and no lawyer for the person under investigation.
  • The prosecutor runs it, choosing the witnesses and the evidence.
  • The rules of evidence are loose. Hearsay is allowed (Costello v. United States, 1956), and so is evidence that would be barred at trial because of how police got it (United States v. Calandra, 1974).
  • The prosecutor need not present evidence that helps the suspect (United States v. Williams, 1992).

A grand jury can also investigate. It can order witnesses to testify and to hand over documents.

If the jurors vote to charge, they return a "true bill." If not, a "no bill."

Grand jury and trial jury

Grand juryTrial jury
DecidesWhether to chargeWhether the defendant is guilty
Size (federal)16 to 2312 in a criminal trial
Vote needed12Unanimous
StandardProbable causeBeyond a reasonable doubt
Open to the public?NoYes
Does the defense take part?NoYes
HearsMany cases over monthsOne case

State courts

The grand jury clause is one of the few parts of the Bill of Rights that does not bind the states. The Supreme Court held so in Hurtado v. California (1884), and that is still the rule.

States therefore choose. Some require a grand jury indictment for serious crimes. Others let a prosecutor file charges directly, with a judge then deciding at a preliminary hearing whether there is probable cause.

The standing criticism

Because the prosecutor controls what the jurors hear, grand juries almost always indict when asked. A New York judge's remark that a prosecutor could get a grand jury to "indict a ham sandwich" has become the usual way of putting it.

Related entries