Grandfather clause
A provision that exempts existing situations from a new rule
In briefA grandfather clause is a provision in a new law or rule that lets people or things already in place continue under the old rules. Someone covered by one is said to be "grandfathered in."
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
The original grandfather clauses
The term has an ugly origin. After Reconstruction, several Southern states adopted literacy tests and property requirements for voting, aimed at excluding Black voters. Those tests would also have excluded many poor white men. To avoid that, the states added exemptions for men who had been entitled to vote around 1866 or 1867, and for their descendants. Since almost no Black men could vote in those states before 1867, the exemption protected white voters only. Louisiana adopted one of the first, in 1898, and several other states followed.
The Supreme Court strikes them down
In Guinn v. United States (1915), the Court, without dissent, struck down Oklahoma's grandfather clause, adopted in 1910. The clause exempted from a literacy test anyone who had been entitled to vote on or before January 1, 1866, or who then lived in a foreign country, and their lineal descendants. The Court held that choosing a date before the Fifteenth Amendment could have no purpose except to deny the vote on account of race, which that amendment forbids.
Oklahoma responded with a 1916 law giving anyone who had not voted in 1914 just twelve days to register or be barred for life. The Court struck that down too in Lane v. Wilson (1939), holding that the Fifteenth Amendment "nullifies sophisticated as well as simple-minded modes of discrimination."
The South relied on other devices, such as poll taxes, literacy tests and white primaries. The Supreme Court struck down white primaries in 1944, and poll taxes and literacy tests were ended in the 1960s by a constitutional amendment, the Voting Rights Act of 1965 and the courts.
Grandfathering today
The phrase lost its racial meaning and now describes any exemption for what already exists. Such clauses are common, because they let a new rule take effect without upsetting settled arrangements.
| Area | Example |
|---|---|
| Zoning | A business that existed before a zoning change may continue as a "nonconforming use," often with limits on expansion |
| Firearms | Federal law bans owning or transferring machine guns, except those lawfully possessed before May 19, 1986 |
| Health insurance | Plans in existence on March 23, 2010, when the Affordable Care Act was signed, were exempted from some of its requirements |
| Environment | Older power plants were exempted from some Clean Air Act standards until they made major modifications |
| Licensing | People already practicing a profession may be exempted from new education or exam requirements |
Why grandfather clauses are used
They protect people who relied on the old rules, reduce opposition to a change, and avoid claims that a new rule unfairly takes away something people already had. In property law, forcing an existing use to stop at once can raise questions under the Takings Clause.
The cost
A grandfather clause can keep an old problem alive for decades. Exempted power plants and grandfathered buildings often continue to operate long after the rule meant to replace them, and critics argue that some exemptions should expire after a set period. Many modern laws include such phase-outs.
Related entries
- StatuteA written law passed by a legislature
- Separate but equalThe rule, from 1896 to 1954, that racial segregation was lawful if facilities were equal
- Plessy v. FergusonThe 1896 case that upheld racial segregation as "separate but equal"
- MoratoriumA legal suspension of an activity or obligation for a period of time
- ContractAn agreement that the law will enforce