Gregg v. Georgia
The 1976 case that upheld the death penalty under new procedures
The ruleThe death penalty for murder is not in itself cruel and unusual punishment, and a law that guides the sentencer's discretion and provides for review can impose it.
Still good law?Yes. It remains the basis of the death penalty in the United States. Later cases have narrowed who may be executed and for what crimes. Checked November 12, 2026.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
The question
After Furman v. Georgia (1972) struck down the death penalty as it was then imposed, Georgia wrote a new law. Troy Gregg was convicted under it of the armed robbery and murder of two men who had given him a ride, and was sentenced to death.
The case, decided with four others from Florida, Texas, North Carolina and Louisiana, raised two questions. Is the death penalty always cruel and unusual punishment? And if not, did Georgia's new law cure the problems the Court had found in Furman?
What the Court held
The death penalty is not always unconstitutional. The Constitution's own text assumes it, the joint opinion noted, since the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments speak of depriving a person of "life" with due process. Most states had passed new death penalty laws since Furman, showing that society had not rejected it. Retribution and deterrence were legitimate purposes, and death was not a disproportionate punishment for deliberate murder.
Georgia's new law was valid. It had three features that answered Furman's concern about arbitrary sentences:
- A separate sentencing hearing after the guilty verdict, at which both sides could present evidence about the punishment
- Guided discretion: the jury had to find at least one of ten listed aggravating circumstances before it could impose death, and could consider anything in mitigation
- Automatic review by the Georgia Supreme Court of every death sentence, including whether it was out of line with sentences in similar cases
How the justices divided
| Position | Justices |
|---|---|
| Joint opinion upholding the law | Stewart, Powell, Stevens |
| Agreed in the result | Burger, White, Rehnquist, Blackmun |
| Dissent: the death penalty is always unconstitutional | Brennan, Marshall |
The companion cases
The same day, the Court upheld the Florida and Texas laws, which also guided the sentencer's choice. It struck down the North Carolina and Louisiana laws, which made death mandatory for certain murders, because they did not allow the sentencer to consider the individual offender (Woodson v. North Carolina). Those two principles, guided discretion and individualized sentencing, still govern.
What followed
Executions resumed in January 1977, when Utah executed Gary Gilmore by firing squad. Nearly 1,700 people have been executed in the United States since.
Later cases have narrowed the death penalty, as the table below shows: by crime, to cases involving killing, and by offender, excluding juveniles and people with intellectual disability. Justices have repeatedly debated whether the system meets Gregg's promise of consistency, but no majority has revisited its central holding.
Where it stands
About 27 states, the federal government and the military have the death penalty in law. Four of those states have paused executions by the governor's order. Executions rose to 47 in 2025 and are concentrated in a few states, led by Florida, which carried out 19 in 2025 and as many again in 2026 by early November, followed by Texas.
How later cases have used it
| Case | How it used this one |
|---|---|
| Coker v. Georgia (1977) | Death is too severe a penalty for the rape of an adult woman. |
| Atkins v. Virginia (2002) | People with intellectual disability may not be executed. |
| Roper v. Simmons (2005) | People who committed their crime before age 18 may not be executed. |
| Kennedy v. Louisiana (2008) | The death penalty may not be imposed for a crime against an individual that did not kill, and was not meant to kill, the victim, here the rape of a child. |
| Glossip v. Gross (2015) | A prisoner challenging a method of execution must show a known and available alternative that would significantly reduce the risk of severe pain. |
| Bucklew v. Precythe (2019) | The same test governs every challenge to a method of execution, including one based on a prisoner's particular medical condition. |
Related entries
- Furman v. GeorgiaThe 1972 case that halted the death penalty across the United States
- Life imprisonmentA sentence to prison for the rest of a person's life
- CommutationA reduction of a criminal sentence by a president or governor
- MurderThe unlawful killing of a person with malice aforethought
- PardonAn act of forgiveness that removes the punishment for a crime