How to fight a traffic ticket
The options after a ticket, what happens in traffic court, and what the state must prove
In briefA driver fights a traffic ticket by pleading not guilty before the deadline printed on it and asking for a hearing, where the government must prove the violation. The other choices are to pay, which usually counts as admitting the violation, or, where the state offers it, to take a driving course that keeps the ticket from counting against the driver. Doing nothing is the worst choice.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
The three options
- Pay the fine. The case ends, but the violation goes on the driving record.
- Contest the ticket. The driver pleads not guilty, usually by mail, online or in person, and the court sets a hearing date.
- Traffic school or a deferral, where offered. In California, an eligible driver who finishes traffic school keeps the point hidden from insurers. In Florida, a driver who elects a driver improvement course is not assessed points, but may not make that choice more than once in 12 months or more than eight times in a lifetime.
A driver who ignores a ticket faces late fees and often a separate charge for failing to appear, and in many states the license can be suspended.
What happens at the hearing
In most states an ordinary ticket is an infraction or other minor offense, not a serious crime, and the hearing is short and informal. A judge or hearing officer decides the case; there is usually no jury. The officer who wrote the ticket usually testifies first. The driver may question the officer, testify, call witnesses, and show photographs, video or diagrams. The driver does not have to testify.
Some states let the whole case be decided on paper. California calls this a trial by written declaration: the driver and the officer each send a written statement, and the judge rules without anyone coming to court.
What the government must prove
The government carries the burden of proof; the driver does not have to prove innocence. How heavy that burden is depends on the state:
| Place | Standard |
|---|---|
| Florida | Beyond a reasonable doubt |
| New York City (Traffic Violations Bureau) | Clear and convincing evidence |
| Michigan (informal hearing) | Preponderance of the evidence, meaning more likely than not |
Common defenses attack the proof: the officer's view was blocked, a sign was missing or hidden, the wrong car was stopped, or the speed-measuring device was not shown to be accurate. Disagreeing with the law, or explaining why the driver was in a hurry, is not a defense, though a judge may consider it in setting the fine.
Points and insurance
A conviction usually adds points to the driver's record, and too many points in a set period leads to suspension. Insurers check driving records and may raise premiums after a moving violation. That is why a reduced charge, or a course that keeps the violation off the record, can be worth more than the fine itself.
Commercial drivers have fewer ways out. Federal rules bar states from using deferrals or diversion programs to keep a commercial license holder's traffic conviction off the record.
When a lawyer helps
Many drivers contest ordinary tickets on their own, and Michigan's informal hearings do not allow lawyers on either side. A lawyer is more useful when the stakes are higher: a license close to suspension, a commercial license, a crash with injuries, or a ticket in a distant court that the lawyer can attend in the driver's place. Charges such as drunk or reckless driving are crimes, with possible jail time, and call for a criminal defense lawyer.
This page describes the legal profession in general terms and is not legal advice.
Related entries
- Traffic ticket lawyers and ticket clinicsHow lawyers handle speeding and traffic tickets, and what volume "ticket clinic" firms do
- DUI lawyerA criminal defense lawyer who handles drunk and drugged driving charges and the license hearing that comes with them
- Burden of proofWho has to prove a case, and how convincingly
- Nolo contendereA plea of no contest: accepting conviction without admitting guilt
- Justice of the peaceA local judicial officer who handles minor cases
- Public defenderA lawyer provided by the government to defend people who cannot afford one