BriefLaw.us
Trials, juries and evidence

Hung jury

A jury that cannot agree on a verdict

In briefA hung jury is a jury that cannot reach the agreement needed for a verdict. The judge then declares a mistrial, and the case ends without a conviction or an acquittal.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

Why juries hang

In a criminal trial for a serious crime, all jurors must agree to convict. In nearly every state all must also agree to acquit, so one holdout either way is enough to hang the jury. Oregon is the exception: it allows an acquittal on a 10–2 vote.

Federal courts have long required unanimity. In Ramos v. Louisiana (2020), the Supreme Court held that the Constitution requires it in state courts too. Before that, Louisiana and Oregon allowed convictions on a 10–2 vote.

Civil trials in many state courts are different. New York, for example, lets a civil jury decide by five-sixths of its members. Federal civil juries must be unanimous unless both sides agree otherwise.

What the judge does first

A judge does not declare a mistrial the moment jurors say they are stuck. The judge can send them back to keep trying, and can give an extra instruction urging them to listen to each other and reconsider. This is called an Allen charge, after Allen v. United States (1896). Critics call it a "dynamite charge" because it presses holdouts. Some states limit it or bar it.

If the jury still cannot agree, the judge declares a mistrial.

What happens next

The prosecutor has three choices:

  • Try the case again with a new jury.
  • Offer a plea bargain, often on better terms for the defendant.
  • Drop the charges.

Why a retrial is not double jeopardy

The Constitution bars trying a person twice for the same offense. A retrial after a hung jury is allowed because the first trial never reached a verdict. The Supreme Court has held this since United States v. Perez (1824).

Split results

A jury can agree on some charges and hang on others. The verdicts it did reach stand, and only the undecided charges can be retried.

CaseWhat it decided
Yeager v. United States (2009)If an acquittal on one charge necessarily decided a fact in the defendant's favor, prosecutors cannot retry a hung charge that depends on the same fact
Blueford v. Arkansas (2012)A foreperson's report that the jury was unanimous against a charge is not an acquittal unless a formal verdict is returned

Related entries