BriefLaw.us
Legal tests

I know it when I see it

Justice Potter Stewart's 1964 phrase about defining obscenity

In brief"I know it when I see it" is the best-known shorthand for a legal standard that resists definition. The phrase comes from a 1964 Supreme Court opinion by Justice Potter Stewart, describing how he decided whether a film was obscene.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

The case

Nico Jacobellis managed a movie theater in Cleveland Heights, Ohio, and was convicted for showing Les Amants (The Lovers), a French film by Louis Malle with a love scene in the last reel. The Supreme Court reversed the conviction, 6–3, but the justices in the majority could not agree on why. There was no majority opinion.

What Stewart wrote

Stewart's concurrence was a single short paragraph. He wrote that the First Amendment allowed only "hard-core pornography" to be banned as obscene, and then:

"I shall not today attempt further to define the kinds of material I understand to be embraced within that shorthand description; and perhaps I could never succeed in intelligibly doing so. But I know it when I see it, and the motion picture involved in this case is not that."

Why the line is quoted

The sentence was candid. Stewart admitted that the line between protected expression and obscenity could not be stated in words that would let anyone predict the answer in advance. That is why it is quoted far beyond obscenity law: as an example of a judge's honest admission of intuition, and as a criticism of standards that give judges unchecked discretion and leave the public without fair warning.

In the years that followed, the Court often decided obscenity cases one at a time, with justices viewing the material themselves and issuing short orders without a shared definition.

What it was not

  • It was not the Court's holding. It was one justice's separate opinion.
  • It was not meant to be a test. Stewart said plainly that he was declining to define the term.
  • It did not say that obscenity is whatever a judge dislikes. His point was that only a narrow category of hard-core material could be banned, and that the film before him was not in it.

The standard the Court adopted

In Miller v. California (1973), a majority agreed on a definition for the first time since Roth v. United States (1957). The Miller test asks whether the average person, applying contemporary community standards, would find that the work appeals to prurient interest; whether it depicts sexual conduct in a patently offensive way as defined by state law; and whether it lacks serious literary, artistic, political or scientific value. Stewart joined the dissent in Miller.

Later life

Stewart, who retired in 1981, reportedly said he regretted that the line would be remembered above anything else he wrote. Judges, lawyers and writers still use it, approvingly or critically, whenever a rule seems to depend on a decision-maker's instinct, from what counts as an unreasonable search to what makes a business practice unfair.

Related entries