BriefLaw.us
Criminal cases

Informant

A person who gives police or prosecutors information about a crime

In briefAn informant is a person who gives law enforcement information about a crime or about the people committing it. Many do so in secret and in exchange for something, such as lighter treatment in their own criminal cases.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

Kinds of informant

KindWho it is
Confidential informantA person who supplies information, and sometimes takes part in an investigation, while the police keep the person's identity secret
Cooperating witness or cooperating defendantA person, often charged in the same case, who agrees to give evidence and usually to testify in open court
Anonymous tipsterA person who passes on information without giving a name, even to the police
Citizen informantA victim or bystander who reports what they saw and asks for nothing in return

Tips and search warrants

Police often rely on an informant's tip to get a search warrant. A judge must then decide whether the tip gives probable cause.

In Illinois v. Gates (1983), the Supreme Court dropped an older two-part test that required separate proof of the informant's reliability and of how the informant knew the facts. Judges now look at the "totality of the circumstances" and ask whether there is a fair probability that evidence of a crime will be found. The tip in that case was an anonymous letter. Police confirmed enough of its details to support a warrant.

Keeping the name secret

The government has a privilege to withhold the identity of people who give it information about crimes. The reason is practical: people will not come forward if their names are exposed.

The privilege has limits. In Roviaro v. United States (1957), the Court held that it gives way when the informant's identity is relevant and helpful to the defense or essential to a fair trial. There is no fixed rule. A judge balances the public interest in the flow of information against the defendant's right to prepare a defense. In Roviaro the informant had helped set up a heroin deal and was the only other person who took part in it, so the name had to be disclosed.

Disclosure is less likely when the only question is whether police had probable cause. In McCray v. Illinois (1967), the Court held that police need not always name an informant at a hearing on whether an arrest or search was lawful.

What informants receive

Many informants are suspects or defendants who cooperate in the hope of leniency. In federal court a prosecutor can ask the judge for a lower sentence because the defendant gave "substantial assistance" in investigating or prosecuting someone else. The request can be made at sentencing or, under Rule 35(b) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, afterward, and it can take a sentence below a mandatory minimum.

Safeguards at trial

A witness who has been promised something has a reason to shade the truth. The law deals with that risk in three main ways.

  • Disclosure of deals. In Giglio v. United States (1972), the Court held that prosecutors must tell the defense about a promise of leniency made to a key witness, because it bears on the witness's credibility.
  • Cross-examination. In Hoffa v. United States (1966), the Court said that an informant's motives to lie do not bar the testimony. They are to be tested by cross-examination and weighed by the jury.
  • The entrapment defense. An informant who works for the police counts as a government agent. If the informant pushes a person into a crime that person was not otherwise ready to commit, the defendant may claim entrapment.

Informants and privacy

A person who confides in someone who turns out to be an informant gets no help from the Fourth Amendment. In Hoffa, the Court held that the amendment does not protect a wrongdoer's misplaced belief that a person he confides in will keep the secret.

Related entries