BriefLaw.us
Criminal defenses

Insanity defense

The claim that mental illness left a defendant not responsible for a crime

In briefThe insanity defense is the argument that a defendant should not be held criminally responsible because a mental illness, at the time of the act, kept him from understanding what he was doing or that it was wrong. "Insanity" here is a legal term, not a medical diagnosis.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

The tests

Courts have used several tests. States choose their own.

TestThe defendant is not responsible if, because of mental illness, he
M'Naghten (England, 1843)did not know what he was doing, or did not know it was wrong
Irresistible impulseknew it was wrong but could not control himself
Model Penal Code (1962)lacked substantial capacity to appreciate that the act was wrong or to conform his conduct to the law
Federal (1984)was unable to appreciate the nature and quality or the wrongfulness of his acts, because of a severe mental disease or defect

The M'Naghten rule and versions of it are the most widely used.

The federal rule

Congress narrowed the federal defense in the Insanity Defense Reform Act of 1984, passed after John Hinckley Jr. was found not guilty by reason of insanity of shooting President Ronald Reagan. The statute:

  • requires a "severe" mental disease or defect
  • drops the "could not control himself" branch
  • puts the burden on the defendant, who must prove insanity by clear and convincing evidence

What the Constitution requires

Very little is fixed. In Clark v. Arizona (2006), the Supreme Court said no single test is required. In Kahler v. Kansas (2020), it held that a state may drop the "did not know it was wrong" defense. Kansas considers mental illness at trial only on the question of whether the defendant had the intent the crime requires, and again at sentencing.

A small number of states take that narrower approach. The Court's opinions name Idaho, Kansas, Montana and Utah. States may also put the burden of proving insanity on the defendant, as the Court held in Leland v. Oregon (1952).

What happens after the verdict

A defendant found not guilty by reason of insanity does not usually go free. He is committed to a psychiatric hospital.

CaseWhat it decided
Jones v. United States (1983)He can be held longer than the maximum prison sentence for the crime
Foucha v. Louisiana (1992)He cannot be held once he is no longer mentally ill

Not the same as competence to stand trial

The two questions concern different times.

  • Insanity looks back to the defendant's state of mind when the act was committed.
  • Competence asks whether the defendant can, right now, understand the proceedings and help his lawyer. The test comes from Dusky v. United States (1960). A defendant who does not meet it is not tried until he does.

A related verdict

Some states offer "guilty but mentally ill." It is a conviction: the defendant is sentenced like any other, with treatment made available while he serves the sentence.

Related entries

Across the Brief network

People in this entry, on BriefPeople