BriefLaw.us
Trials, juries and evidence

Jury

A group of citizens sworn to decide the facts in a trial

In briefA jury is a group of ordinary citizens sworn to hear the evidence in a trial and decide the facts. In a criminal case it decides whether the prosecution has proved guilt. In a civil case it decides who should win and, often, how much is owed. The judge decides questions of law and instructs the jury on what the law is. This entry is about the trial jury, also called the petit jury. A grand jury is a different body that decides whether to bring charges.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

The right to a jury

Case typeSourceScope
CriminalSixth Amendment and Article IIIAny offense punishable by more than six months in prison (Baldwin v. New York, 1970)
Civil, federal courtSeventh Amendment"Suits at common law" worth more than $20, mainly claims for money damages
Civil, state courtState constitutionsThe Seventh Amendment does not bind the states

The Supreme Court applied the criminal jury right to the states in Duncan v. Louisiana (1968). The Seventh Amendment has never been applied to the states, though nearly all state constitutions guarantee civil juries. The Court declined to revisit the question in 2025.

Either side can usually give up the right. A criminal defendant may choose a trial by judge alone, called a bench trial, with a written waiver, the prosecutor's consent and the court's approval in federal cases.

Size

CaseRule
Williams v. Florida (1970)A six-person jury in a criminal case is constitutional
Ballew v. Georgia (1978)A five-person jury is not
Federal criminal trials12 jurors, unless the parties agree in writing, with the judge's approval, to fewer; the judge may also let 11 finish if one is excused during deliberations
Federal civil trialsMust start with 6 to 12 jurors

The Supreme Court has agreed to reconsider whether the Constitution requires 12 jurors in serious criminal cases, in Kian v. Florida, set for argument on January 13, 2027.

Unanimity

A criminal conviction requires a unanimous jury, in state as well as federal court (Ramos v. Louisiana, 2020). Before Ramos, Louisiana and Oregon had allowed convictions by 10–2 votes.

In federal civil cases the verdict must be unanimous unless the parties agree otherwise. Many states allow non-unanimous verdicts in civil cases, often by five-sixths or three-quarters.

If jurors cannot agree, the jury is "hung" and the judge declares a mistrial.

Who serves

Jurors are drawn at random from lists such as voter rolls and driver's license records. The pool must represent a fair cross section of the community (Taylor v. Louisiana, 1975), and no one may be excluded because of race or sex. Most courts require jurors to be citizens, adults, residents of the area and able to understand English, and exclude people with certain criminal convictions.

From that pool, the judge and lawyers question prospective jurors and remove those who cannot be impartial, in the process called voir dire.

What the jury does not do

Jurors decide the facts and apply the law as the judge explains it. They do not decide what the law is. In most criminal cases they also do not decide the sentence; the judge does. The main exception is the death penalty, where a jury must find the facts that make a defendant eligible for it (Ring v. Arizona, 2002), and in most death-penalty states the jury also decides or recommends the sentence.

Apart from a prior conviction, any fact that raises the maximum sentence must also be found by a jury beyond a reasonable doubt (Apprendi v. New Jersey, 2000).

Deliberations

Deliberations are secret. A verdict generally cannot be challenged with evidence of what jurors said to each other. The exception is clear evidence that a juror relied on racial bias as a significant motivating factor in voting to convict (Peña-Rodriguez v. Colorado, 2017).

Related entries