Jury nullification
A jury's acquittal of a defendant it believes guilty, because it rejects the law or its use
In briefJury nullification happens when a jury finds a defendant not guilty even though it believes the evidence proves guilt, because it considers the law unjust or its use in that case unfair. The jury in effect "nullifies" the law for that defendant.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
Why it is possible
Nullification is not a legal right that courts recognize. It is a consequence of two rules that are.
- An acquittal is final. The Double Jeopardy Clause bars the government from appealing a not-guilty verdict or trying the defendant again.
- Jurors need not explain a general verdict. Their deliberations are secret, and they cannot be punished for their verdict. That principle goes back to Bushel's Case (1670), in which an English court freed the juror Edward Bushel, who had been jailed for refusing to pay a fine imposed because the jury acquitted the Quakers William Penn and William Mead.
Together, these mean a jury has the power to acquit for any reason, and no one can undo it.
History
Some of the best-known acquittals in American history are examples.
- John Peter Zenger (1735). A New York jury acquitted the printer of seditious libel against the colonial governor, although under the law of the time what he printed was enough to convict.
- The fugitive slave laws. Northern juries in the 1850s sometimes refused to convict people charged with helping escaped slaves.
- Prohibition. Juries often refused to convict under alcohol laws in the 1920s.
Nullification has also been used for injustice. In the civil rights era, white juries in the South acquitted white defendants accused of violence against Black people despite strong evidence.
How courts treat it
The Supreme Court held in Sparf v. United States (1895) that a federal jury must take the law from the judge and that a defendant is not entitled to an instruction that the jury may decide the law for itself.
Courts since have followed the same approach.
- No instruction. Federal judges, and judges in most states, do not tell jurors they may disregard the law. In United States v. Dougherty (1972), the D.C. Circuit acknowledged the jury's power but held that the defense had no right to have the jury told of it.
- No argument. Lawyers generally may not urge jurors to nullify.
- Removal of jurors. A judge may remove a juror during deliberations who announces a refusal to follow the law, though courts are cautious because the line between that and simple disagreement about the evidence is hard to draw.
- Screening. During jury selection, prospective jurors are asked whether they will follow the judge's instructions.
A few state constitutions, including those of Georgia, Indiana and Maryland, say that juries in criminal cases are judges of the law as well as the facts. Courts in those states generally hold that jurors must still follow the judge's instructions on the law, though Indiana gives its provision some practical effect and a state statute there requires judges to tell juries of the right. New Hampshire, by a 2012 statute, lets the defense tell the jury it may judge how the law applies to the facts.
Limits
Nullification works only in one direction. A jury cannot convict a defendant against the law or the evidence; a judge can set aside a conviction the evidence does not support. And a single holdout who refuses to convict produces a hung jury, not an acquittal, so the defendant can be tried again.
The debate
Supporters see nullification as a check on unjust laws and overzealous prosecution, rooted in the jury's role as the conscience of the community. Critics answer that it lets twelve people override laws passed by elected legislatures, invites inconsistent and biased verdicts, and is dangerous precisely because no one can review it.
People who hand out leaflets about jury nullification near courthouses have sometimes been charged with jury tampering. In the best-known cases, in New York in 2012 and Colorado in 2019, the charges were dismissed.
Related entries
- JuryA group of citizens sworn to decide the facts in a trial
- AcquittalA finding that the prosecution did not prove a criminal charge
- Double jeopardyThe rule against trying a person twice for the same crime
- Voir direThe questioning of prospective jurors to choose a fair jury
- Reasonable doubtThe level of proof needed to convict someone of a crime
- Hung juryA jury that cannot agree on a verdict
Across the Brief network
People in this entry, on BriefPeople