BriefLaw.us
Lawyers, judges and officials

Justice of the peace

A local judicial officer who handles minor cases

In briefA justice of the peace is a local judicial officer who handles minor legal matters, such as traffic tickets, small debts and petty crimes. In some states the office still holds a court; in others it survives mainly to perform marriages and witness documents.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

Origin

The office began in England in the 1300s, when the Crown appointed local landowners to keep the peace in each county. It came to the American colonies and was for a long time the court most Americans dealt with. Marbury v. Madison (1803), the case that established judicial review, began as a dispute over commissions for justices of the peace in the District of Columbia.

What a justice of the peace does today

Duties are set by each state and vary widely.

DutyExamples
Minor criminal casesTraffic violations and misdemeanors punishable by fine only
Small civil casesDebt claims and small claims below a set amount, up to $20,000 in Texas
Landlord and tenantEviction cases
Early stages of criminal casesIssuing warrants, setting bail, holding inquests in some places
CeremonialPerforming marriages, taking oaths and acknowledging signatures

Texas has one of the largest systems. Each county has between one and eight justice of the peace precincts, and the elected justices hear a large share of the state's cases. Arizona, Louisiana and several other states also have justice courts. In many New England states the title is given to people who mainly perform weddings and certify documents.

Some states have abolished the office or replaced it with magistrates or municipal judges.

Qualifications

Many states do not require a justice of the peace to be a lawyer. In Texas, for example, the office is elected, there are no formal qualifications, and very few justices are lawyers, but each must complete 80 hours of training in the first year and 20 hours every year after.

The Supreme Court has allowed this, with a safeguard. In North v. Russell (1976), it held that a defendant may be tried by a judge who is not a lawyer, in that case a city police judge, for a minor offense carrying jail time, if the defendant has the right to a new trial before a lawyer-judge on appeal.

Fairness

The Constitution limits how such courts may be run. In Tumey v. Ohio (1927), a village mayor sitting as a judge was paid his court fees only when he convicted the defendant. The Court held that a judge with a direct financial interest in convicting violates due process. The same rule applies to any justice of the peace whose pay depends on finding defendants guilty.

Appeals

Decisions of a justice court can usually be appealed to a county or district court, which often hears the whole case again from the start rather than reviewing the record.

The title elsewhere

Justices of the peace still sit in England and Wales, where they are called magistrates. They are unpaid, and sit in the magistrates' courts, where about 95 percent of criminal cases are completed. Canada, Australia and other Commonwealth countries have the office in various forms.

Related entries