BriefLaw.us
Lawyers, judges and officials

Legal malpractice and complaints against lawyers

Suing a lawyer for a costly mistake, and reporting a lawyer for misconduct

In briefLegal malpractice is a lawsuit for money against a lawyer whose carelessness or breach of duty caused a client a financial loss. It is separate from a complaint to the state's lawyer discipline agency, which asks the state to investigate and, if warranted, discipline the lawyer but does not award damages. A client can pursue either or both.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

Legal malpractice

Legal malpractice is a claim that a lawyer's carelessness or breach of duty caused a client to lose money. To win, a client generally must prove:

  1. A lawyer-client relationship.
  2. A breach of duty, meaning the lawyer failed to act as a reasonably careful lawyer would, for example by missing a filing deadline, failing to investigate, or having a conflict of interest.
  3. Causation, often the hardest part: that the client would have done better without the mistake. In litigation, this can mean proving the underlying case would have been won, a "case within a case."
  4. Damages, an actual financial loss.

Losing a case is not malpractice in itself, and neither is a reasonable strategic choice that did not work. Malpractice claims have short deadlines under each state's statute of limitations. In many states a person convicted of a crime must first have the conviction overturned before suing their defense lawyer.

Complaints to the bar

Every state has an agency, usually under the state supreme court and often run through the state bar, that investigates complaints of lawyer misconduct. Common complaints include:

  • neglecting a case or failing to communicate
  • mishandling or taking client money
  • dishonesty or conflicts of interest
  • charging unreasonable fees

Filing is free and usually done online or with a form. The agency reviews the complaint, may ask the lawyer to respond, and dismisses most complaints that do not show a violation of the ethics rules. A bar complaint is not a lawsuit and does not award damages, though discipline can include an order that the lawyer repay the client (restitution).

Discipline

Sanctions, from least to most serious, include a private warning (admonition), a public reprimand, suspension, and disbarment, which revokes the license. Probation can be imposed alone or along with another sanction. Discipline records are often public and can be checked on the state bar or supreme court website.

Other help

  • Fee disputes can often be resolved through a state or local bar's fee arbitration program.
  • Client protection funds, run by state bars or courts, can repay clients when a lawyer steals their money, up to a set limit.

This page describes the process in general terms and is not legal advice.

Related entries