BriefLaw.us
Lawyers, judges and officials

Magistrate

A judicial officer with limited powers, below the level of a full trial judge

In briefA magistrate is a judicial officer who handles a limited set of matters, such as issuing warrants, setting bail and deciding minor cases, rather than the full range of a trial judge's work. In the federal courts the office is the United States magistrate judge. In the states the title covers many different jobs.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

Federal magistrate judges

Magistrate judges are officers of the federal district courts, the trial courts of the federal system. Congress created the office in 1968 to replace the U.S. commissioners, who had served since the 1790s. A 1990 law changed the title from "magistrate" to "magistrate judge."

Magistrate judgeDistrict judge
Chosen byThe district judges of the court, by majority voteThe President, with Senate confirmation
Term8 years full-time, 4 years part-time; renewableLife, during good behavior
RemovalBy the court, for incompetency, misconduct, neglect of duty or disabilityOnly by impeachment and conviction

A magistrate judge must generally have been a member of the bar for at least five years. A panel of local residents, lawyers and non-lawyers, reviews the applicants and recommends candidates to the court. The rules are in 28 U.S.C. § 631 and in regulations of the Judicial Conference.

What federal magistrate judges do

Their powers come from 28 U.S.C. § 636 and from what each district court assigns to them.

  • Early steps in criminal cases. Issuing warrants, holding first appearances and arraignments, and deciding whether a defendant is released or held before trial.
  • Minor criminal cases. Trying petty offenses, and other misdemeanors if the defendant consents in writing or on the record. A defendant charged with a misdemeanor that is not petty may insist on a district judge.
  • Pretrial matters. Deciding most pretrial disputes in civil and criminal cases. A district judge can overturn such a ruling only if it is clearly wrong or contrary to law.
  • Recommendations. On weightier motions, such as a motion for summary judgment or for an injunction, the magistrate judge writes proposed findings and a recommendation. The parties have 14 days to object, and a district judge then decides the disputed points afresh.
  • Civil trials by consent. If every party agrees, a magistrate judge can run a whole civil case, including a jury trial, and enter judgment. An appeal then goes straight to the court of appeals. Parties are free to refuse.

Felony trials remain with district judges.

State magistrates

In state courts the word has no single meaning. Depending on the state, a magistrate may be a judge of a lower court, an officer who issues warrants and sets bail, or a helper who hears matters for a judge. Qualifications, terms and methods of selection all vary, and in some states a magistrate need not be a lawyer.

South Carolina is one example. Its magistrates are appointed by the governor with the consent of the state senate for four-year terms. They generally hear criminal cases punishable by a fine of up to $500 or 30 days in jail, and civil claims of $7,500 or less.

Magistrate and justice of the peace

The two offices overlap. Both handle minor cases and the first steps of criminal cases, and some states that abolished the justice of the peace gave the work to magistrates. In England and Wales, justices of the peace are themselves called magistrates.

The older, wider meaning

In older usage, "magistrate" can mean any public official with authority, including a judge of any rank. Court opinions on search warrants often speak of a "neutral and detached magistrate," meaning whichever judicial officer issues the warrant.

Related entries