Marbury v. Madison
The 1803 case that lets courts refuse to apply unconstitutional laws
The ruleWhen a law conflicts with the Constitution, a court must follow the Constitution and refuse to apply the law.
Still good law?Yes. It has never been overruled or narrowed, and the Supreme Court quoted it as recently as 2024 and 2026. Checked November 11, 2026.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
The question
William Marbury was appointed a justice of the peace, but the new administration refused to hand over his commission. He asked the Supreme Court to order Secretary of State James Madison to deliver it. The legal question that mattered was whether the Supreme Court had the power to hear his request at all.
What the Court held
Marshall answered three questions in order:
- Did Marbury have a right to the commission? Yes. It was complete once signed and sealed.
- Did the law give him a remedy? Yes. Where a legal right is violated, the law provides a way to enforce it.
- Could the Supreme Court give that remedy? No. Section 13 of the Judiciary Act of 1789 let Marbury start his case in the Supreme Court. Article III of the Constitution lists the cases that may start there, and this was not one of them. Congress cannot add to the list, so Section 13 was void.
The three rules lawyers take from it
1. Judicial review. Courts decide whether a law is consistent with the Constitution, and a law that is not has no effect. The line quoted most often is:
"It is emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is."
2. Officials can be ordered to do a legal duty, but not how to use their judgment. Marshall separated two kinds of executive action. A ministerial act is one the law requires, such as delivering a signed commission. A court can order it. A political act is one left to the president's discretion. A court cannot review it. In his words, "Questions, in their nature political, or which are, by the constitution and laws, submitted to the executive, can never be made in this court." This is the root of the modern political question doctrine.
3. Congress cannot enlarge the Supreme Court's original jurisdiction. The cases that can begin in the Supreme Court are fixed by Article III. This is the narrow holding, and it still governs.
What it did not decide
- It did not say the courts have the only word on the Constitution. The opinion says courts must apply the Constitution in the cases before them. The stronger claim, that the Court's reading binds every other official, came in Cooper v. Aaron (1958).
- It did not concern state laws. The Court first struck down a state law for conflicting with the Constitution itself in Fletcher v. Peck (1810). In Ware v. Hylton (1796) it had already set aside a Virginia law that conflicted with a federal treaty.
- It did not make judicial review routine. The Court did not strike down another act of Congress until 1857.
Both sides cite it
Since 2024 the case has been used to widen what courts decide (Loper Bright) and to restrict what courts may order (CASA). The table below lists the main uses.
How later cases have used it
| Case | How it used this one |
|---|---|
| Cooper v. Aaron (1958) | Read Marbury to mean the federal courts are "supreme in the exposition of the law of the Constitution," so state officials must follow the Court's rulings. |
| United States v. Nixon (1974) | Quoted "say what the law is" to reject the president's claim that he alone decides what executive privilege covers. |
| City of Boerne v. Flores (1997) | Relied on it to hold that Congress cannot change the meaning of a constitutional right by passing a statute. |
| Loper Bright v. Raimondo (2024) | Quoted it in overruling Chevron: courts, not agencies, decide what a statute means. |
| Trump v. CASA (2025) | The majority cited it for the limits on court power: Marshall found the law had been broken and still held he could not issue the order. |
| Trump v. Slaughter (2026) | The dissent cited Marshall's remark that Marbury's office was "not removable at the will of the executive." The majority answered that Marbury "has nothing to do with this one." |
Related entries
Across the Brief network
People in this entry, on BriefPeople