BriefLaw.us
Lawyers, judges and officials

Mass tort

Many individual injury lawsuits against the same defendants, managed together

In briefA mass tort is a large group of separate lawsuits brought by people who say they were injured by the same product or event, such as a drug, a medical device, a chemical leak or a plane crash. It is not one case. Each injured person has an individual claim, usually an individual lawyer, and in the end an individual payment, but courts manage the cases together because they raise the same questions about what the defendant did.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

Mass tort vs. class action

Mass tortClass action
Who suesEach person files, or signs up with a lawyer to file, a separate caseA few representatives sue for everyone in the class
Taking partA person must act to bring a claimClass members are usually included unless they opt out
ProofEach person must show an injury and what caused itCommon proof for the whole class
PaymentVaries with each person's injurySet by one formula for the class
Typical claimsSerious physical injuries that differ from person to personSimilar, often small, money losses

Injury cases rarely qualify as class actions because each person's medical history, harm and damages differ.

Multidistrict litigation

When similar cases are filed in federal courts around the country, a panel of seven federal judges, the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation, can transfer them to one judge. A federal law, 28 U.S.C. 1407, allows this when the cases share common questions of fact. The grouped cases are called a multidistrict litigation, or MDL. The panel says it has created more than 1,800 MDLs since 1968.

The MDL judge handles pretrial work once for all the cases: exchange of evidence, questioning of company witnesses, and rulings on expert testimony. The judge usually appoints a small group of plaintiffs' lawyers to lead that work. A federal rule added in 2025, Rule 16.1, sets out how judges should organize an MDL early on. By law, a case that is not resolved must be sent back to its original court for trial.

Bellwether trials

MDL judges often pick a few representative cases for early trials, called bellwether trials. The verdicts bind only those plaintiffs, but they show both sides how juries react to the evidence and what claims may be worth, which often leads to settlement talks.

How claimants are paid

Most mass torts end in a broad settlement, not in thousands of trials. A typical deal sets up a fund and a point system or set of tiers, so that payment depends on factors such as the type and severity of the injury, the person's age, and the strength of the proof that the product was used. Each person submits medical and other records to a claims administrator, receives an offer, and decides whether to accept it. Before the money is paid, the lawyer's fee and case costs are subtracted, and medical bills that insurers or government health programs paid for the injury often must be repaid from the award.

Lawyers' fees

Mass tort lawyers almost always work on a contingency fee, a percentage of the client's recovery set in a written agreement, with no fee if nothing is recovered. In an MDL, the judge may also order that a share of each recovery go to a common fund that pays the lead lawyers for work that benefited every claimant. People often ask whether that share comes out of the lawyer's percentage or is added to it.

Each state's filing deadline still applies to each person, so joining late can mean losing the claim.

This page describes the legal profession in general terms and is not legal advice.

Related entries