BriefLaw.us
Contracts and business

Memorandum of understanding

A document recording what parties have agreed in outline, often without binding them

In briefA memorandum of understanding, or MOU, is a written document that records what two or more parties have agreed in broad terms. It is commonly used to set out a shared intention before, or instead of, a formal contract.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

What it is for

  • Before a deal. Parties record the main terms they have reached so far and what remains to be negotiated.
  • Cooperation without a deal. Government agencies, universities and nonprofits use MOUs to describe how they will work together, share information or divide responsibilities, where no money changes hands and no one expects to sue.
  • Between governments. Countries use MOUs for arrangements they do not intend to be treaties.

A letter of intent and a term sheet do much the same job in business deals.

Is an MOU binding?

The title does not decide. A document called a memorandum of understanding can be an enforceable contract, and a document called a contract can fail to be one. Courts ask two questions.

  1. Did the parties intend to be bound? Courts look at the words used and at how the parties behaved.
  2. Are the terms definite enough to enforce? An agreement that leaves essential terms, such as price, for later is an "agreement to agree" and generally cannot be enforced.
Points toward bindingPoints toward non-binding
"The parties agree," "shall," "will""The parties intend," "may," "hope to"
All essential terms settledKey terms left open
No mention of a later contract"Subject to a definitive agreement"
Signatures by people with authorityA statement that the document creates no legal obligations
One side has begun performingNothing has been done in reliance

Partly binding documents

Many MOUs are deliberately mixed. The outline of the deal is stated to be non-binding, while a few clauses are made binding:

  • confidentiality
  • exclusivity, a promise not to negotiate with others for a period
  • who pays the costs of negotiating
  • which state's law governs

The duty to negotiate in good faith

Even where the main deal is not binding, some courts enforce a promise to keep negotiating in good faith. In SIGA Technologies v. PharmAthene (2013), the Delaware Supreme Court held that a promise to negotiate a license in good faith on the terms of an attached term sheet was enforceable, and that a party who breaks it in bad faith can be made to pay the profits the other side would have earned. SIGA had demanded far better terms. In 2015 the court upheld an award of $113 million. Not every state goes that far.

The warning case

In Texaco v. Pennzoil, Pennzoil and Getty Oil had announced an "agreement in principle" for a purchase, with a formal contract still to be signed. Texaco then bought Getty. A Texas jury in 1985 found that the earlier agreement was binding and that Texaco had interfered with it, and awarded $10.53 billion. An appeals court upheld the finding in 1987 while reducing the punitive part. The case is the standard reminder that a preliminary document can bind.

Keeping an MOU non-binding

Parties who do not want to be bound should say so in plain words: that the document is not a contract, that neither side has any obligation until a final written agreement is signed, and which clauses, if any, are exceptions. They should also avoid acting as if the deal were done.

Government MOUs

An MOU between two agencies of the same government is generally an administrative arrangement, not a contract that a court would enforce. An MOU between a government body and a private party is judged by the ordinary rules above.

Related entries