Mens rea
The guilty state of mind that most crimes require
In briefMens rea is the state of mind a person must have had for an act to be a crime. The phrase is Latin for "guilty mind." Most crimes need two things: a prohibited act (the actus reus) and a mental state that goes with it, such as intent or recklessness. The prosecution must prove both.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
Why it matters
The same act can be a serious crime, a lesser crime or no crime at all, depending on what was in the person's mind. Someone who picks up another traveler's suitcase by mistake has not stolen it. A driver who kills a pedestrian may be guilty of murder, manslaughter or nothing, depending on whether the death was intended, risked or a pure accident. Oliver Wendell Holmes, later a Supreme Court justice, put it this way: "even a dog distinguishes between being stumbled over and being kicked."
The four levels
Older law sorted crimes into "general intent" and "specific intent," terms that caused confusion. The Model Penal Code, a model statute that many states have drawn on, replaced them with four mental states, from most to least blameworthy.
| Mental state | What it means | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Purposely | The person's conscious aim was to do the act or cause the result | Firing a gun at someone in order to kill |
| Knowingly | The person was practically certain the result would follow | Blowing up a building for the insurance, aware that people are inside |
| Recklessly | The person was aware of a substantial and unjustified risk and ignored it | Firing a gun into the air in a crowded street |
| Negligently | The person was not aware of the risk but should have been | Leaving a loaded gun where children play |
Each state uses its own wording. New York, for example, defines four culpable mental states: intentionally, knowingly, recklessly and with criminal negligence. A minority of states still speak of "malice."
A crime's definition says which level is needed, and a lower level often means a lesser crime. That is the usual difference between murder and manslaughter.
What mens rea is not
- Knowledge of the law. The person must know the facts that make the conduct a crime, but usually need not know that the conduct is illegal.
- Motive. Motive is the reason for acting. A good motive does not cancel a guilty mind, and the prosecution does not usually have to prove motive at all.
Crimes with no mens rea
A strict liability crime needs only the act. The prosecution does not have to prove any guilty state of mind. Statutory rape is a common example: in many states a mistake about the other person's age is no defense. Many minor regulatory offenses work the same way.
When the statute is silent
Many statutes do not say what mental state is required. Federal courts generally assume that one is.
- In Morissette v. United States (1952), a scrap collector took spent bomb casings from an Air Force range, believing they were abandoned. The Supreme Court reversed his conviction, holding that the statute's silence about intent did not remove the intent requirement from a crime rooted in the common law.
- In Elonis v. United States (2015), the Court said that a statute with no stated mental state is read to include the one needed to separate wrongful conduct from innocent conduct.
- In Rehaif v. United States (2019), it held that a person charged with possessing a gun while barred from having one must have known both that he had the gun and that he belonged to the barred group.
Related entries
- FelonyA serious crime, usually one punishable by more than a year in prison
- MurderThe unlawful killing of a person with malice aforethought
- ManslaughterAn unlawful killing without the malice that makes it murder
- BurglaryUnlawfully entering a building with the intent to commit a crime inside
- Insanity defenseThe claim that mental illness left a defendant not responsible for a crime
- Statutory rapeSexual activity with a person below the age of consent, a crime even without force