Miller test
The three-part test for deciding whether material is legally obscene
In briefThe Miller test is the standard American courts use to decide whether material is obscene. Obscenity is not protected by the First Amendment, so material that meets the test can be banned or punished. Material that does not meet it is protected speech, however sexually explicit.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
The test
In Miller v. California (1973), the Supreme Court held that a work is obscene only if all three of the following are true.
| Question | Measured by |
|---|---|
| Would the average person, applying contemporary community standards, find that the work, taken as a whole, appeals to the prurient interest? | Contemporary community standards, state or local, not national |
| Does the work depict or describe, in a patently offensive way, sexual conduct specifically defined by the applicable state law? | Contemporary community standards, state or local, not national |
| Does the work, taken as a whole, lack serious literary, artistic, political or scientific value? | An objective, reasonable-person standard, not community standards (Pope v. Illinois, 1987) |
Why it was needed
For years before Miller the justices had been unable to agree on a definition. One of them, Potter Stewart, famously said he would not try to define hard-core pornography but knew it when he saw it. Miller gave states a test they could write into their laws and juries could apply.
Marvin Miller had mailed unsolicited advertising brochures with explicit pictures. The Court, by 5–4, sent his case back to be judged under the new standard.
How it works in practice
- "Taken as a whole." A work is judged in its entirety, not by isolated passages.
- Community standards vary. The same material could be obscene in one place and not in another, because juries apply the standards of their own communities.
- The law must be specific. A state must define in its statutes the kinds of sexual conduct whose depiction it forbids.
- Serious value saves a work. A book, film or picture with real artistic or political value is protected even if a community finds it offensive.
Limits around the test
- Private possession. A person may not be punished for merely possessing obscene material at home (Stanley v. Georgia, 1969). Selling, distributing and importing it can still be punished.
- Child sexual abuse material is a separate category. It can be banned without meeting the Miller test, because the harm is to the children used to make it (New York v. Ferber, 1982).
- Material harmful to minors. States may restrict minors' access to sexual material that would be protected for adults (Ginsberg v. New York, 1968). In Free Speech Coalition v. Paxton (2025), the Court upheld, 6–3, a Texas law requiring age verification for commercial websites where more than a third of the content is sexual material harmful to minors.
- Indecency on broadcast radio and television is regulated under a separate, broader standard.
The internet problem
Community standards were designed for a world of local bookstores and theaters. Material online reaches every community at once. In Ashcroft v. ACLU (2002), the Court held that relying on community standards did not by itself make a federal online law substantially overbroad; the law was later kept blocked on other grounds. Several justices warned that a national medium might call for a national standard. The question has never been fully settled.
How often it is used
Prosecutions for adult obscenity are now rare. The test matters mostly as the reason most sexual expression is constitutionally protected.
Related entries
- I know it when I see itJustice Potter Stewart's 1964 phrase about defining obscenity
- Chilling effectWhen a law or threat discourages people from exercising a right, especially free speech
- PrecedentAn earlier court decision that later courts follow
- Schenck v. United StatesThe 1919 case that created the "clear and present danger" test for speech
- Tinker v. Des MoinesThe 1969 case that protects student speech in public schools