BriefLaw.us
Criminal defenses

M'Naghten rules

The classic test for legal insanity: not knowing what you were doing, or that it was wrong

In briefThe M'Naghten rules are the traditional test for whether a defendant is legally insane and so not responsible for a crime. They ask whether mental illness kept the defendant from knowing what they were doing, or from knowing that it was wrong.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

The case

In 1843 Daniel M'Naghten, a Scottish woodturner who believed he was being persecuted by the Tories, Peel's party, shot Edward Drummond, the private secretary of the Prime Minister, Sir Robert Peel. Drummond died days later. He appears to have mistaken Drummond for Peel. A jury found him not guilty by reason of insanity, and he spent the rest of his life in asylums.

The verdict caused public outrage. Queen Victoria, herself the target of assassination attempts, wrote to Peel to complain. The House of Lords put a series of questions to the senior judges, and their answers became the test.

The test

The judges said a defendant is presumed sane, and that to establish insanity it must be clearly proved that:

at the time of the committing of the act, the party accused was labouring under such a defect of reason, from disease of the mind, as not to know the nature and quality of the act he was doing; or, if he did know it, that he did not know he was doing what was wrong.

There are two separate ways to meet it:

BranchExample
Not knowing the nature and quality of the actA person who strangles someone believing they are squeezing a lemon
Not knowing the act was wrongA person who kills because they believe God has commanded it

A person who knows what they are doing and that it is wrong, but cannot control themselves, is not insane under M'Naghten.

Other tests

TestQuestionStatus
Irresistible impulseCould the defendant control their conduct?Added to M'Naghten in a few states
Product test (New Hampshire since 1870; federal courts in Washington, D.C., under the Durham rule, 1954–1972)Was the crime the product of mental disease?Used only in New Hampshire today
Model Penal Code (1962)Did the defendant lack substantial capacity to appreciate the wrongfulness of the conduct or to conform to the law?Used in a substantial minority of states

The federal rule after Hinckley

In 1982 John Hinckley Jr. was found not guilty by reason of insanity of shooting President Reagan, under the broader Model Penal Code test then used in federal courts, which required the prosecution to prove sanity beyond a reasonable doubt. Congress responded with the Insanity Defense Reform Act of 1984, which returned the federal courts to a version of M'Naghten. A defendant must show that, because of a severe mental disease or defect, they were unable to appreciate the nature and quality or the wrongfulness of their acts. The defendant must prove this by clear and convincing evidence.

Many states also tightened their rules after Hinckley, by narrowing the test, putting the burden on the defendant, or adding a "guilty but mentally ill" verdict.

What the Constitution requires

Very little. In Clark v. Arizona (2006), the Supreme Court upheld a state test limited to whether the defendant knew the act was wrong. In Kahler v. Kansas (2020), it upheld a Kansas law that allows mental illness to be considered only on whether the defendant had the intent the crime requires, and at sentencing, without a separate defense based on not knowing the act was wrong. Kansas, Idaho, Montana and Utah have no separate insanity defense.

After the verdict

A defendant found not guilty by reason of insanity is not simply released. In most cases they are committed to a psychiatric hospital, sometimes for longer than a prison sentence would have lasted.

Related entries