Modus operandi
A person's characteristic way of committing a crime
In briefIn criminal law, modus operandi (usually shortened to M.O.) is the particular method a person uses to commit crimes. The phrase is Latin for "way of operating."
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
How investigators use it
People who commit crimes repeatedly tend to repeat what has worked: the kind of target, the time of day, the way of getting in, the tools, the words spoken. Police compare these details across unsolved cases to decide whether one person may be responsible for several of them.
An M.O. is different from a motive. Motive is why a crime was committed. M.O. is how.
The problem in court
A basic rule of evidence is that a person is tried for the crime charged, not for their past. Under Federal Rule of Evidence 404(b), evidence of other crimes or acts cannot be used to show that a person has a bad character and so probably did it again.
The same rule allows other-acts evidence for a different purpose, "such as proving motive, opportunity, intent, preparation, plan, knowledge, identity, absence of mistake, or lack of accident." Modus operandi evidence comes in under this part of the rule, most often to prove identity: the charged crime was committed in so particular a way that it points to the person known to have committed other crimes in the same way.
How distinctive it must be
Because the risk of unfair prejudice is high, courts demand a close match. Similarities common to many crimes of the same type are not enough. That two robberies were both committed with a handgun by a man in a mask proves little.
Courts often say the method must be so unusual and distinctive as to be like a signature. They look at:
- how many features the crimes share
- how unusual those features are
- how close the crimes are in time and place
- whether there are important differences
The safeguards
| Safeguard | What it requires |
|---|---|
| Proper purpose | The evidence must be offered for something other than character, such as identity |
| Enough proof of the other act | There must be enough evidence for a jury reasonably to find that the defendant committed it (Huddleston v. United States, 1988). A prior conviction is not required. |
| Balancing (Rule 403) | The judge may exclude the evidence if its value is substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice |
| Notice | In a criminal case the prosecutor must give reasonable written notice before trial of the evidence, the purpose for which it is offered and the reasoning behind it. A judge can excuse late notice for good cause. |
| Instruction | On request, the judge tells the jury to consider the evidence only for the permitted purpose |
A defendant can use the same reasoning in reverse, offering evidence that someone else with the same M.O. committed the crime.
M.O. and "signature"
Criminal investigators sometimes draw a line that courts do not. To them, an M.O. is what the offender does to carry out the crime and get away, and it can change with experience. A signature is behavior that goes beyond what the crime requires and tends to stay the same.
Outside criminal law
The phrase is also used loosely for any habitual way of working, such as a company's usual business practice. That use has no special legal meaning.