BriefLaw.us
The legal system

Moratorium

A legal suspension of an activity or obligation for a period of time

In briefA moratorium is a legally authorized pause: a period during which an activity is suspended or an obligation need not be met. It is usually temporary and usually adopted in an emergency or while a problem is studied.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

Common kinds

KindWhat is pausedExample
DebtForeclosures or loan paymentsState mortgage moratoriums in the Great Depression; the federal pause on student loan payments from 2020 to 2023
EvictionRemoving tenants for unpaid rentThe federal eviction moratorium during the COVID-19 pandemic
DevelopmentNew building permits or certain land usesLocal pauses on construction while a town writes a new plan
ExecutionsCarrying out death sentencesGovernors' moratoriums in several states
Natural resourcesDrilling, fishing or miningThe pause on deepwater drilling after the 2010 Gulf of Mexico oil spill

A bankruptcy filing works like a moratorium for one debtor: the automatic stay stops creditors from collecting while the case proceeds.

Debt moratoriums and the Constitution

The Constitution forbids states to pass laws "impairing the Obligation of Contracts." In Home Building & Loan Association v. Blaisdell (1934), the Supreme Court nonetheless upheld, 5–4, a Minnesota law that let courts extend the time homeowners had to redeem foreclosed property during the Depression. The Court held that a state may use its police power in a genuine emergency, if the relief is reasonable and temporary and the debt is not wiped out.

The federal eviction moratorium

In September 2020 the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention ordered a nationwide halt to evictions of tenants who could not pay rent because of the pandemic. Congress extended it once, by a month. After that ran out, the CDC extended the order several more times on its own and then issued a new one. In Alabama Association of Realtors v. Department of Health and Human Services (2021), the Supreme Court, 6–3, let a lower-court ruling against the order take effect. It said the CDC had very likely exceeded its powers, and that a pause of that scope needed specific authorization from Congress.

Building moratoriums and takings

Property owners have argued that a long ban on building takes their property without compensation. In Tahoe-Sierra Preservation Council v. Tahoe Regional Planning Agency (2002), the Supreme Court held that two building moratoriums around Lake Tahoe, lasting a combined 32 months, were not automatically a taking. Courts weigh the facts of each case, and a moratorium that drags on can still require compensation.

Death penalty moratoriums

A governor can stop executions by granting reprieves, even when state law keeps the death penalty in place. Governors in California, Oregon and Pennsylvania have declared moratoriums, and Ohio's governor has repeatedly postponed every scheduled execution. A moratorium does not change any sentence, and a later governor can end it.

Other uses

  • Lawmaking. Legislatures sometimes forbid an activity for a set time, such as a ban on new state regulation of an industry, sometimes with a sunset date.
  • International. States and organizations agree on moratoriums such as the International Whaling Commission's pause on commercial whaling, in force since 1986, though a few countries do not follow it.

Related entries