BriefLaw.us
Crimes

Murder

The unlawful killing of a person with malice aforethought

In briefMurder is the most serious form of criminal homicide: an unlawful killing with "malice aforethought," which means intent to kill or seriously injure, extreme recklessness toward human life, or a death during certain dangerous felonies. That is the definition in federal law and the traditional one in most states.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

What "malice aforethought" means

The phrase is old and misleading. It does not require hatred, and it does not always require planning. Courts treat any of four states of mind as malice:

  1. intent to kill
  2. intent to cause serious bodily injury
  3. extreme recklessness that shows indifference to human life, sometimes called a "depraved heart"
  4. taking part in certain dangerous felonies during which someone dies, under the felony murder rule

First and second degree

Most states and the federal government divide murder into degrees. The details vary, but the usual pattern is this.

DegreeWhat it covers
First degreeA killing that is willful, deliberate and premeditated, and killings in the course of listed felonies such as robbery, burglary, kidnapping and arson
Second degreeAny other murder: an intended killing without premeditation, or a death caused by extreme recklessness

Premeditation does not need much time. Courts have held that the decision to kill can be formed moments before the act, so long as there was time to reflect.

Felony murder

Under the felony murder rule, a person who takes part in a dangerous felony can be guilty of murder if someone dies during it, even without intending a death. A getaway driver can be convicted of murder for a killing by an accomplice inside. Some states have narrowed or dropped the rule.

Murder and manslaughter

Manslaughter is an unlawful killing without malice. A killing in the heat of passion after serious provocation, or a death caused by recklessness short of the extreme kind, is manslaughter, not murder.

Limits on punishment

Federal first-degree murder is punished by death or life in prison. The Supreme Court has set constitutional limits that apply to every state.

CaseLimit
Enmund v. Florida (1982) and Tison v. Arizona (1987)An accomplice in a felony murder can be executed only if he killed, intended a killing, or was a major participant who showed reckless indifference to life
Roper v. Simmons (2005)No death penalty for a crime committed under age 18
Kennedy v. Louisiana (2008)No death penalty for a crime against an individual in which the victim did not die
Miller v. Alabama (2012)No mandatory sentence of life without parole for a crime committed under age 18

Defenses

A killing in lawful self-defense is not murder. Other defenses, such as insanity, can remove criminal responsibility. A claim of provocation does not excuse the killing but can reduce murder to manslaughter.

Related entries