New York Times Co. v. United States
The 1971 Pentagon Papers case on stopping publication in advance
The ruleThe government could not stop the New York Times and the Washington Post from publishing the Pentagon Papers. It carries a heavy burden to justify a court order that stops the press from publishing, and a general claim of harm to national security does not meet it.
Still good law?Yes. It has not been overruled or narrowed, and courts still treat an order barring publication in advance as presumptively unconstitutional. Checked November 11, 2026.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
The question
In June 1971 the New York Times began publishing excerpts from a classified Defense Department history of the Vietnam War, known as the Pentagon Papers. The Washington Post followed. The government asked federal courts to order both newspapers to stop, saying further publication would harm national security. The question was whether a court can bar a newspaper from publishing information in advance.
What the Court held
Not on this showing. The Court's unsigned opinion is three paragraphs long. It says that any system of prior restraints on expression comes to the Court "bearing a heavy presumption against its constitutional validity," that the government "thus carries a heavy burden" to justify one, and that the government had not met that burden.
The case moved at unusual speed. The Court heard argument on June 26 and decided on June 30, seventeen days after the first article appeared. Each of the nine justices wrote separately. Six voted for the newspapers and three dissented.
Why there is no single reasoning
The six justices in the majority agreed on the result but not on why.
- Justices Black and Douglas thought the First Amendment bars prior restraints on the press almost absolutely.
- Justice Brennan would allow one only on proof that publication would cause an immediate and direct danger, of the kind a wartime report of troop movements would.
- Justices Stewart and White stressed that Congress had passed no law authorizing such an order, and that the government had not shown direct, immediate and irreparable harm. White added that he thought publication would do real damage and that criminal prosecution remained open.
- Justice Marshall pointed out that Congress had considered giving the government this power and declined, so the courts could not create it.
What it did not decide
- It did not say prior restraints are never allowed. The Court in Near v. Minnesota (1931) had named narrow exceptions, such as publishing the sailing dates of troop ships in wartime, and this case left them in place.
- It did not protect the newspapers or the leaker from prosecution afterward. Several justices said criminal charges under existing laws remained possible. Daniel Ellsberg, who leaked the papers, was prosecuted; the charges were dismissed in 1973 because of government misconduct.
- It did not decide what the public has a right to know. The case was about stopping publication, not about access to government records.
Prior restraint and later punishment
The distinction at the heart of the case is between two ways of dealing with speech.
| Prior restraint | Later punishment | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | An order not to publish | A lawsuit or prosecution after publication |
| Example | An injunction against a newspaper | A defamation suit |
| How courts treat it | Presumed unconstitutional | Allowed within First Amendment limits |
How later cases have used it
| Case | How it used this one |
|---|---|
| Nebraska Press Association v. Stuart (1976) | Applied the same presumption to strike down a judge's order barring the press from reporting on a criminal case before trial. |
| Snepp v. United States (1980) | A former CIA officer could be held to his signed agreement to submit writings for review before publication. A contract with an employee is treated differently from an order against the press. |
| Bartnicki v. Vopper (2001) | A broadcaster who lawfully received a recording that someone else had made illegally could not be held liable for airing it, where it concerned a matter of public interest. |
Related entries
Across the Brief network
People in this entry, on BriefPeople