BriefLaw.us
Legal tests

Originalism

Reading the Constitution according to its meaning when it was adopted

In briefOriginalism is a theory of how to interpret the Constitution. It holds that the Constitution's words have the meaning they had when they were adopted, and that judges should apply that meaning unless the Constitution is changed by amendment.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

The basic claims

  1. Fixation. The meaning of each provision was fixed when it was ratified: 1788 for most of the original document, 1791 for the Bill of Rights, 1868 for the Fourteenth Amendment.
  2. Constraint. Judges are bound by that meaning and should not substitute their own views about what would be good policy.

Originalists argue that this is what it means to have a written constitution, that it keeps unelected judges from making law, and that it leaves change to the amendment process and to elected legislatures.

Versions

VersionWhat it looks for
Original intentWhat the framers and ratifiers meant to accomplish
Original public meaningHow an ordinary, informed reader would have understood the words at the time. This is the dominant version today.
Original methodsThe methods of interpretation lawyers used at the time

The shift from intent to public meaning came in the 1980s, partly because the intentions of hundreds of framers and ratifiers were hard to identify and often conflicting.

The rival view

Living constitutionalism holds that the Constitution's broad principles, such as "equal protection," "due process" and "cruel and unusual punishments," should be applied in light of changing circumstances and values. Its supporters argue that the framers chose general language on purpose, and that a document written in the 18th century cannot be applied to modern society by history alone.

Many judges fall between the two, giving weight to text and history as well as to precedent and practical consequences.

History

Appeals to original meaning are as old as American constitutional law. The modern movement began in the 1970s and 1980s, as a response to the Warren and Burger Courts. Attorney General Edwin Meese promoted a "jurisprudence of original intention" in 1985, and Justice Antonin Scalia, appointed in 1986, became its leading voice on the Court.

Originalism on the Court today

Originalist reasoning now shapes many of the Court's major decisions.

  • District of Columbia v. Heller (2008): the Second Amendment protects an individual right, based on the public meaning of its words in 1791.
  • New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen (2022): a gun law that burdens conduct the Second Amendment covers is valid only if the government shows it is consistent with the nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation.
  • Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022): overruled Roe v. Wade, holding that abortion is not a right "deeply rooted in this Nation's history and tradition."
  • Trump v. Barbara (2026): the majority rested on the history of the Citizenship Clause, from English common law through its adoption in 1868, and on the 1898 Wong Kim Ark precedent. The three dissenters read the same history differently.

Criticisms

  • Indeterminacy. History is often unclear, and originalists themselves frequently disagree about the answer.
  • Judges as historians. Judges are not trained historians and may select the evidence that supports their preferred outcome.
  • Excluded voices. The meaning is drawn from a period when most people could not vote.
  • Precedent. Strict originalism could unsettle long-accepted decisions; most originalist judges accept some precedents they consider mistaken.

Supporters reply that every method of interpretation has these problems and that originalism at least ties judges to something outside themselves.

Related entries

Across the Brief network

People in this entry, on BriefPeople