BriefLaw.us
Civil lawsuits

Prejudice

In law, harm to a party's rights, or a dismissal's effect on refiling

In briefIn law, prejudice means harm to a person's legal rights or position, not bias in the everyday sense. Its most common use is in dismissals: a case dismissed with prejudice cannot be brought again, while one dismissed without prejudice can be refiled. The word also appears in appeals and in rules about evidence.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

Dismissal with or without prejudice

When a court dismisses a case, the order says whether the dismissal is with or without prejudice.

DismissalEffect
With prejudiceFinal. The plaintiff cannot bring the same claim again. It has the same effect as a judgment on the merits.
Without prejudiceThe plaintiff may refile, if the deadline for suing has not passed

The federal civil rule

Rule 41 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure sets the defaults.

  • A plaintiff's voluntary dismissal, made before the other side answers or moves for summary judgment, or by agreement of all parties, is without prejudice unless it says otherwise.
  • The two-dismissal rule: if a plaintiff has already dismissed an earlier lawsuit, in federal or state court, based on the same claim, a second notice of dismissal acts as a judgment on the merits.
  • An involuntary dismissal, such as for failing to prosecute the case or to obey court orders, acts as a judgment on the merits unless the order says otherwise. Dismissals for lack of jurisdiction, improper venue or failure to join a required party are exceptions.

Criminal cases

A charge dismissed without prejudice may be brought again, subject to the statute of limitations. A dismissal with prejudice bars further prosecution for that offense.

Under the federal Speedy Trial Act, when a deadline is missed the court decides whether to dismiss with or without prejudice, weighing, among other things, the seriousness of the offense, the facts and circumstances that led to the dismissal, and the effect of a new prosecution on the Speedy Trial Act and on the administration of justice.

Prejudice in appeals

Most errors at trial do not lead to a new trial unless they caused prejudice, meaning they affected the outcome or a party's substantial rights. An error that did not is called harmless.

The same idea governs claims that a defense lawyer was ineffective. Under Strickland v. Washington (1984), the defendant must show both that the lawyer's performance was deficient and that it caused prejudice: a reasonable probability that, without the errors, the result would have been different.

Some errors are treated as prejudicial without any further showing, such as being denied a lawyer altogether or being tried by a biased judge.

Unfair prejudice in evidence

Under Federal Rule of Evidence 403, a judge may exclude relevant evidence if its probative value is substantially outweighed by a danger of unfair prejudice, or of confusion, delay and similar problems. All good evidence harms the other side; the rule is aimed at evidence that would lead a jury to decide on an improper basis, such as emotion or a defendant's bad character, rather than on the facts.

Other uses

  • "Without prejudice" in negotiations. In settlement letters, especially in Britain, the phrase means the statement cannot later be used in court as an admission.
  • Prejudicial publicity. Pretrial news coverage that may prevent a fair trial can justify moving the trial or questioning jurors more closely.
  • Prejudice to the other side is also one of the factors courts weigh when a party asks for a delay, to amend its pleadings, or to excuse a missed deadline.

Related entries