BriefLaw.us
Legal Latin and phrases

Prima facie

Enough evidence, on first view, to support a claim unless it is answered

In briefIn law, prima facie describes evidence enough to establish a fact or claim unless the other side answers it. A prima facie case is strong enough to go forward; it is not yet a win. It is Latin for "at first sight."

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

A prima facie case

Every legal claim is made up of elements, the separate things that must be proved. A party makes a prima facie case by offering evidence on each element that, if believed, would let a judge or jury find in that party's favor.

Making a prima facie case does not mean winning. It means the case is strong enough to go forward. The other side then has the chance to answer with its own evidence.

What happens if it is not made

If the party who carries the burden of proof fails to make a prima facie case, the other side can ask the judge to end the case without presenting any defense. Depending on the stage, this is a motion to dismiss, for summary judgment, or for judgment as a matter of law. In a criminal trial it is a motion for a judgment of acquittal.

What happens if it is made

The other side must respond or risk losing. Lawyers say the burden of production shifts: the opponent must come forward with evidence. The burden of persuasion, the duty to convince the judge or jury in the end, usually stays where it started.

The best-known example: job discrimination

An employee who claims discrimination rarely has direct proof of the employer's motive. In McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. Green (1973), the Supreme Court set out three steps for such cases.

  1. The employee makes a prima facie case. In a hiring case, that means showing that the person belongs to a protected group, applied and was qualified for an open job, was rejected, and that the job stayed open while the employer kept looking for people with the same qualifications.
  2. The employer gives a lawful reason for its decision.
  3. The employee tries to show the reason is a pretext, a cover for discrimination.

The first step is meant to be easy. In Texas Department of Community Affairs v. Burdine (1981), the Court called the burden "not onerous" and made clear that the employee keeps the burden of persuasion throughout.

In Ames v. Ohio Department of Youth Services (2025), the Court held unanimously that the first step is the same for everyone. Courts may not demand extra evidence from a plaintiff who belongs to a majority group.

Other uses

SettingWhat prima facie means there
Jury selectionA defendant who shows facts suggesting that a prosecutor removed jurors because of race has made a prima facie case, and the prosecutor must give a neutral explanation (Batson v. Kentucky, 1986)
StatutesA law may make one fact "prima facie evidence" of another. For example, a copyright registration made before or within five years after a work is first published is prima facie evidence that the copyright is valid.
NegligenceIn some states, breaking a safety law is prima facie evidence of carelessness
Preliminary hearingsIn some states the prosecution must make a prima facie case to hold the accused for trial; in federal court the test is probable cause

Prima facie and related ideas

  • A presumption is a rule that requires a conclusion from certain facts unless the other side rebuts it. A prima facie case often works through one.
  • Probable cause is the standard for an arrest or a search. It asks a different question, though it is also a threshold short of proof.
  • Proof comes only at the end, when the judge or jury weighs all the evidence against the required standard.

In ordinary speech the phrase is also used as an adjective meaning "apparent," as in "a prima facie violation."

Related entries