Reasonable doubt
The level of proof needed to convict someone of a crime
In briefReasonable doubt is the standard a jury uses in a criminal trial. To convict, jurors must be convinced of the defendant's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. If a real doubt based on reason remains, they must acquit.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
What it means
The phrase does not appear in the Constitution, and no single definition is required. The idea is that the evidence must leave jurors firmly convinced. It does not require certainty: proof beyond all possible doubt is not the test, because almost anything can be doubted.
A reasonable doubt is one based on reason and the evidence, or the lack of evidence. A doubt based on sympathy, guesswork or a wish to avoid an unpleasant duty does not count.
Where it comes from
The standard is centuries old in English and American courts. The Supreme Court made it a constitutional requirement in In re Winship (1970): due process requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt of every fact needed to make out the crime charged. Winship itself was a juvenile case, so the rule covers juvenile proceedings as well as adult trials.
Why courts avoid defining it
Judges disagree on whether explaining the phrase helps jurors or confuses them.
| Case | What it decided |
|---|---|
| Cage v. Louisiana (1990) | An instruction that described reasonable doubt as "grave uncertainty" and "actual substantial doubt" set the bar too low for the prosecution |
| Sullivan v. Louisiana (1993) | A defective reasonable doubt instruction can never be harmless error; the conviction must be reversed |
| Victor v. Nebraska (1994) | The Constitution requires no particular wording, so long as the instructions as a whole convey the standard correctly |
Some courts give a definition. Others tell jurors only that the words mean what they say.
It is not a number
Courts do not attach a percentage to reasonable doubt, and judges generally bar lawyers from doing so. It is higher than the two civil standards, "more likely than not" and "clear and convincing evidence," but the law leaves the gap unmeasured.
What must be proved to that standard
- Every element of the crime. If the prosecution fails on one element, the jury must acquit on that charge.
- Facts that raise the maximum sentence. Under Apprendi v. New Jersey (2000), any fact that increases the penalty beyond the legal maximum, other than a prior conviction, must be found by a jury beyond a reasonable doubt.
Not everything in a criminal case meets this standard. A judge decides most questions about what evidence comes in, and most sentencing facts within the legal range, on a lower standard.
Its partner: the presumption of innocence
The defendant starts the trial presumed innocent. The reasonable doubt standard is how that presumption works in practice: it stays in place unless and until the prosecution's proof overcomes it.