BriefLaw.us
Legal tests

Res ipsa loquitur

When an accident itself suggests that someone was negligent

In briefRes ipsa loquitur is a rule in the law of negligence that lets a jury infer that the defendant was careless from the nature of the accident itself, when the plaintiff cannot show exactly what the defendant did wrong. The Latin means "the thing speaks for itself."

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

The problem it solves

A person suing for negligence normally must prove that the defendant failed to take reasonable care. But some accidents happen in ways the victim cannot see or explain. The doctrine allows the case to go forward when the accident is the kind that does not normally happen unless someone was careless.

The classic case

In Byrne v. Boadle (1863), a barrel of flour fell from an upper floor of a flour dealer's premises and struck a man walking below. He had no idea how it happened. The English court held that he did not need to: barrels do not fall out of buildings unless someone has been careless, and the warehouse owner was in control. Chief Baron Pollock used the Latin phrase in the case.

The elements

Most American courts require the plaintiff to show:

  1. The accident is of a kind that ordinarily does not happen without negligence.
  2. The thing that caused it was under the defendant's control (many courts now say the defendant was responsible for it).
  3. The plaintiff did not contribute to it. Under modern comparative fault rules, many states have relaxed this element.

Typical examples

  • a surgical instrument left inside a patient
  • an elevator that suddenly drops
  • a falling object from a building or a construction site
  • a train or plane crash in ordinary conditions
  • a soda bottle that explodes in a customer's hand

Medical cases

In Ybarra v. Spangard (1944), a patient woke from an appendix operation with a paralyzed shoulder. He could not know which of the several doctors and nurses had injured him while he was unconscious. The California Supreme Court allowed him to use res ipsa loquitur against every doctor and nurse who had control of him or the equipment during the operation, requiring each to explain what happened. The case is a well-known extension of the doctrine to situations with several possible defendants.

Many states now limit the doctrine in medical malpractice cases, often requiring expert testimony unless the negligence would be obvious to a lay person.

What it does at trial

In most states res ipsa loquitur lets the case reach the jury. The jury may infer negligence, but does not have to. The defendant can offer evidence of what actually happened or of the care taken, and the jury weighs it.

A few states give it a stronger effect. In California, for example, it creates a presumption that shifts to the defendant the burden of producing evidence.

What it is not

  • It is not strict liability. The plaintiff still must show the accident was probably caused by negligence.
  • It is not proof of causation. The plaintiff must still show that the accident caused the injury.
  • It does not apply when the cause is known. If the evidence shows exactly what happened, the jury decides on that evidence instead.

Related entries