BriefLaw.us
Family

Right to die

The right to refuse life-sustaining treatment, and the debate over medical aid in dying

In brief"Right to die" is a broad term for legal questions about how much control a person has over the end of their own life. In American law it covers two different things: the right to refuse medical treatment, which is well established, and medical aid in dying, which is allowed in some states and banned in others.

Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.

Refusing treatment

A competent adult may refuse any medical treatment, including treatment needed to stay alive, such as a ventilator, dialysis or a feeding tube. This rests on the common-law rule that treatment without consent is a battery, and on the doctrine of informed consent.

The hard cases involve patients who can no longer speak for themselves.

  • In re Quinlan (New Jersey, 1976): the father of Karen Ann Quinlan, who was in a persistent vegetative state, was allowed to have her ventilator removed.
  • Cruzan v. Director, Missouri Department of Health (1990): the Supreme Court assumed that a competent person has a constitutionally protected right to refuse life-sustaining treatment, including food and water given through a tube. But it held, 5–4, that a state may require clear and convincing evidence of an incompetent patient's wishes before treatment is withdrawn.
  • Terri Schiavo (2005): after years of litigation between her husband and her parents, Florida courts allowed her feeding tube to be removed. Congress passed an emergency law letting federal courts review the case, but they declined to intervene, and she died soon after.

Advance directives

After Cruzan, Congress passed the Patient Self-Determination Act of 1990, which requires hospitals, nursing homes, home health agencies, hospices and health plans that take Medicare or Medicaid to tell adult patients in writing about their rights under state law to refuse treatment and make advance directives, and to note in the record whether they have one. Advance directives include:

  • A living will: written instructions about the treatment a person wants or refuses if they cannot decide
  • A health care power of attorney: naming someone to make medical decisions for the person

A related document, the do-not-resuscitate order, is written by a doctor, often based on the patient's wishes.

Medical aid in dying

Medical aid in dying, sometimes called physician-assisted suicide or death with dignity, lets a terminally ill adult obtain a prescription for drugs to end their own life.

The Supreme Court held in Washington v. Glucksberg and Vacco v. Quill (both 1997) that there is no constitutional right to it, and that states may ban it. It also held, 6–3, in Gonzales v. Oregon (2006), that the U.S. Attorney General could not use federal drug law to stop doctors from prescribing under a state law that allows it.

Oregon's voters approved the first such law in 1994, and it took effect in 1997. As of late 2026, 13 states and the District of Columbia allow medical aid in dying: 12 states and the District by statute, most recently Delaware, New York and Illinois, and Montana by court ruling. Typical requirements are:

  • the patient is an adult, in most states a state resident, with a terminal illness and a prognosis of six months or less
  • two clinicians, usually doctors, confirm the diagnosis and the patient's capacity
  • the patient makes repeated requests, with a waiting period that varies by state
  • the patient takes the medication themselves

In most states, assisting a suicide outside such a law remains a crime.

The debate

Supporters see these laws as respecting autonomy and relieving suffering. Opponents raise concerns about pressure on elderly, disabled or poor patients, about mistaken prognoses, and about the role of doctors. Disability rights groups have been among the most consistent critics.

Related entries