Self-defense
The right to use reasonable force to protect yourself from imminent harm
In briefSelf-defense is the right to use reasonable force to protect oneself from an imminent threat of unlawful harm. In criminal law it is a justification: a person who acts in lawful self-defense has committed no crime, even if they injure or kill the attacker.
Not legal advice. This page is general information, not legal advice. Anyone facing a real decision should talk to a lawyer licensed in their state; laws change, and exceptions can apply.
The basic requirements
Although the details vary by state, a claim of self-defense generally requires:
- An unlawful threat of force against the defendant
- Imminence: the threat is happening now or about to happen, not at some later time
- A reasonable belief that force is necessary. The belief must be honest and one a reasonable person in the same situation would hold, though it need not turn out to be correct.
- Proportionality: the force used is not more than necessary to meet the threat
Deadly force
Deadly force, meaning force likely to cause death or serious injury, is justified only against a threat of death, serious bodily injury, and in many states certain serious felonies such as kidnapping, rape or robbery. A punch generally cannot be answered with a gun.
The duty to retreat
States differ on whether a person must try to escape before using deadly force.
| Rule | What it requires |
|---|---|
| Duty to retreat | Deadly force is allowed only if the person cannot safely retreat |
| Stand your ground | No duty to retreat from any place the person is lawfully present |
| Castle doctrine | No duty to retreat in one's own home, and in some states one's car or workplace |
Utah passed the first stand-your-ground law in 1994, but Florida's 2005 law started a wave of them, and a majority of states now have the rule, by statute or court decision. Most states also recognize some form of the castle doctrine.
The idea is old. In Brown v. United States (1921), Justice Holmes wrote that "detached reflection cannot be demanded in the presence of an uplifted knife," and the Court held that a person who reasonably believes he faces death or serious injury need not retreat; failing to retreat is only one factor for the jury to weigh.
When the defense is lost
- The initial aggressor generally cannot claim self-defense, unless they clearly withdraw from the fight and the other person continues, or, in some states, the other side escalates to deadly force and there is no safe way out.
- Provocation: a person who deliberately provokes an attack to have an excuse to use force cannot claim it.
- Excessive force: once the threat ends, further force is not self-defense.
Some states recognize imperfect self-defense: a defendant who honestly but unreasonably believed deadly force was necessary may be convicted of manslaughter instead of murder.
Who must prove what
The defendant must first raise the issue with some evidence. In nearly every state the prosecution must then disprove self-defense beyond a reasonable doubt. The Constitution does not require that allocation: in Martin v. Ohio (1987), the Supreme Court upheld a law that required the defendant to prove self-defense by a preponderance of the evidence, but Ohio itself changed the rule in 2019.
Some stand-your-ground states also give a defendant a pretrial hearing at which a judge can grant immunity from prosecution.
Defending others and property
- Defense of others: a person may use the same force to protect another that the other could lawfully use.
- Defense of property: reasonable non-deadly force may be used to protect property, but deadly force generally may not, except as allowed by the castle doctrine.
Civil suits
Self-defense is also a defense to a civil lawsuit for assault, battery or wrongful death. Some stand-your-ground laws give immunity from civil suits as well.
Related entries
- HomicideThe killing of one person by another, whether or not it is a crime
- MurderThe unlawful killing of a person with malice aforethought
- ManslaughterAn unlawful killing without the malice that makes it murder
- AssaultThreatening or attempting to hurt someone, and in many states actually doing so
- BatteryIntentionally touching another person in a harmful or offensive way without consent
- District of Columbia v. HellerThe 2008 case that recognized an individual right to keep a gun at home
- EntrapmentA defense when government agents induce a person to commit a crime they were not inclined to commit